OK, so I was a balm user the first two years of my wet shaving life, and have just recently gotten into old school splashes with the summer heat being here. Anyway, Captains choice was the only brand that really blew me away until today. Shaved with a vintage Puma 6/8 and MWF, rubbed and rinsed the alum, them splashed on some Alt-Innsbruck I just got from WCS. I wasn't sure what to expect, but I couldn't be more pleased. The menthol feel really is amazing, and my skin feels great. The smell is a bit more cologne-y than I am used too, but it's very nice. Overall, I am just amazed at this stuff and see what all the hype is about. Just had to post my thoughts. Probably been done to death, but on well.