Mennen Afta and Calvin Klein Obsession. I have never gotten along with the fragrance of any Nivea product.
I use balms 90% of the time. I have trouble with flaky skin, but my skin is also oily. Figure that one out...These are mine in order.
Myrsol Emulsion with its lanolin goodness. Pre, Post, both. I will literally never run out of that as long as Myrsol keeps making it.
DRH Milk is awesomeness. Pick your favorite scent. Mine are Arlington and Windsor in that order. Lanolin is in there. That's huge for me.
This particular proraso is a new found treat: http://www.italianbarber.com/proraso-white-balm-alcohol-free-aftershave-100ml
I'Coloniali Mango or Rhubarb. No preference between the 2 although the Mango actually smells like concentrated Old Spice to me so I have to wait for weekends as it's too strong for M-F office use.
Institut Karite. I pair it with Tabac soap for a total powder bomb. I prefer it to the Tabac splash as I don't feel so old man. I'd love to try Tabac balm but haven't. I feel the IK on my face literally all day. It's like a moisturizing mask.
Tcheon Fung Sing. Currently on my first long term test of this while I 3017 some Don Marco. It has skin care in spades. Definitely a great balm.
I have the Nivea Sensitive balm which was a favorite for a long time but it's fallen way behind all of the ones I listed above.
I need to pick up Speick as the splash is my #1 splash by a HUGE margin.