I would prefer live also but it might be tough getting everyone on at the same time that's all.
So we've got 8 people interested, need a few more but we might as well start it up now.
Consider doing it through mlb.com... Their fantasy baseball lets you pick up a whole teams pitching rotation... Makes following & altering rotations a whole lot easier (especially for virgins)
As for a reward for the winner, the losers could all send blades or soap, or something shaving related... Kind of sort of a PIF?!?
Never tried MLB.com but open to that as well if the majority wants that.