Do TOBS Aftershaves and Colognes NOT match their Shave Creams?

[Tat2d Bald Dude]

I have read some reviews this week that have indicated that two great TOBS aftershave and colognes are TOBS Sandalwood and TOBS Mr Taylor, but that there is one negative thought. That the aftershaves and colognes of those scents don't match the shave creams at all. Is that true?

[wagstaff]

The Jermyn St. AS scent certainly matches the cream.
I like the scent.... I don't like the implementation in the AS, though. Too strong for too little product (and it's basically atomized mineral oil, from what I can tell). The scent is strong enough and lasts long enough that maybe you could use it as an EdT, though. (It might be better that way).

Don't know about the Sandalwood or the Mr. Taylor, sorry to say. I've used the Sandalwood AS (from Garry's sample shop); I have not tried the cream, though. Haven't used either in the Mr. Taylor.

[nelson]

I have read some reviews this week that have indicated that two great TOBS aftershave and colognes are TOBS Sandalwood and TOBS Mr Taylor, but that there is one negative thought. That the aftershaves and colognes of those scents don't match the shave creams at all. Is that true?

I use the Sandalwood and Mr. Taylor shaving creams and colognes. The scents of the colognes and shaving creams are very, very similar. My experience with these products goes way back, before this web site was created.

[Feek]

I think all the Shaving Shop products match and fit. I often use Shaving Shop cream, Shaving Shop aftershave balm then Shaving Shop cologne and a dose of Shaving Shop aftershave splash.

[john parker]

I use TOBS Sandalwood soap, edt and aftershave; they match very closely.

[5thou]

x2, the wife loves the TOBS Sandalwood cream and aftershave.