Most efficient razor: Mühle R41 vs. Fatip vs. Merkur Slant ?

[gus1942]

I already have SC NEW (and love it). Is LC that much different?

I don't have the SC New but am looking. Most of the guys seem to think YMMV.

[Triad]

Well I read on the forums all the time that Slants are very efficient without being too aggressive. That's why I'm curious about one.

To clear things up, I wonder which of the three is as as efficient as possible but not aggressive to the point that shaving becomes work and not pleasure. I like aggressive razors, but not crazy aggressive if that makes sense.

Gotcha, I think the fatip will impress you it puts a lot of curvature in the blade which makes for a smooth shave where the r41 is flat and can be a little irritating

[Gam]

I find the Joris to be a smoother and a lil more efficient shave than the FaTips,even the FaTips with aftermarket handles.Having said that,the difference is very small and very much a YMMV.Like vocalistbob said both get the job done and I'll add the slant to that as it's also a great shave.

[Dr Roadrash]

If efficiency is defined as most stubble removed per pass I don't even think this is a YMMV thing. Each razor is in a completely different class.
I can't see how anyone could come to a different conclusion:
R41>Fatip>Merkur 37C
Aaron

[PFP_Dad]

I define efficiency as the ability to quickly perform a great shave with minimal risk of irritation (this is part of my goal and if I have to slow down to accomplish it, I am inherently less efficient.) As a result I choose the slant, though I believe there are better vintage options than the 37c. This razor and it's older brother consistently give me smooth, effortless shaves with minimal pass(es).

[brother cavefish]

No contest
the r421 with the bulldog handle, is the best aggressive razor known to the civilized world
mildest
de89 with the same handle

[alex2363]

Fatip....

[AABCDS]

No contest - 2011 R41

[rob_NH]

I find the R41 is not that slow going for me. I use it with a feather, and a new blade every 6 passes (currently every 3 shaves). I don't understand the need to slow down or fear it. The only thing is that you need to learn to use it. The optimum blade angle requires a diffent handle angle than other razors I suspect, and I think the reason some find it too aggressive or irritating is they don't ever learn this angle.

I can't compare it to the others on this list yet, but I shave fast and both blood and irritation free with an R41 and a feather.

[WickedSwde]

Have all three and when you ask for efficient razor I would rank 1st place 37C, Runner up R41 and on a 3rd place Fatip.
If you had ask for an agressive razor it will be R41, R41, Fatip and 37C.

I guess that for those who compare Joris with Fatip price. You pay a bit more for fit & finish on Joris.

[kaiseris]

I guess that for those who compare Joris with Fatip price. You pay a bit more for fit & finish on Joris.

Well, price of Joris 4 times bigger than Fatip's. But again, it's everyones's choice how to spend their money.

[Samjax]

I own all the ones listed (actually a 39C instead of the 37C). I think that my best very close shaves at present come with the Fatip/Tradere handle combo. It is extremely well balanced, cuts very, very close - BUT - it's not harsh - which for me, the R41 sometimes is. The R41 shaves closer - but at least for me, the Fatip shaves better. I'm going to pick up a new Joris as well...just need to decide upon the right handle. Does anyone know which handle has the best grip? And which is the heaviest?

[turtle]

Well I read on the forums all the time that Slants are very efficient without being too aggressive. That's why I'm curious about one.

To clear things up, I wonder which of the three is as as efficient as possible but not aggressive to the point that shaving becomes work and not pleasure. I like aggressive razors, but not crazy aggressive if that makes sense.

Get a slant, either a 37c HD or a 39c Barber Pole.

I have all that you mention (including the long handle 39c).

The most efficient safety razor I have found is the Classic Shaving Cobra which uses disposable straight razor blades.

[dreadpirate]

The Slant HANDS DOWN!! The Fatip second. The R41 is VERY aggressive. The slant provides as close a shave as the R41 but is way smoother, IMO. Unless you like an insanely aggressive shave, don't get the R41.

[rob_NH]

I'm not sure how to define aggressive other than efficient. I find the R41 does not attack me. It is not agressive like that. It attacks my hair, thus it is efficient. I guess I'll lern more wen I get my joris, slant and LC New some time down the road.

[chongo gordo]

Disclaimer: I have never used an R41.

Fatip above the Merkur by significant margin. I think the Merkur is interesting, and will keep trying with it, but it's a much mildr shave than the Fatip, and kinda bulky. And not in that good Fatboy-style-bulky, but just a little cumbersome.

[Teddyboy]

Fatip with a Weber bulldog handle...you won't be sorry even if something else is "more efficient."

[kaiseris]

Though Fatip gets least poll votes somehow it's most attractive to so far.

[turtle]

Though Fatip gets least poll votes somehow it's most attractive to so far.

If you are going to lean to the Fatip, make the leap and get a Joris. Same head, far better fit and finish

[kaiseris]

Thanks Turtle, but as I've already mentioned before, Joris is "too rich for my blood". I couldn't justify spending that much money on a razor (4x price of Fatip). "Bling" isn't my first priority. Not that I don't like it though