You are forced to thin your soap herd to 3...which ones?

[BigWill]

QCS Vostok
Palmolive menthol cream
Proraso green

Definitely a menthol person.

[Absolute Mustard]

MWF
Tabac
DR Marlborough

[gwav64]

Off topic: Just ordered Mystic Waters Lily of the Valley soap, due to several mentions in this thread. ENABLERS! Good grief, Charlie Brown!

[Tim_McD]

This another one of those threads I enjoyed more as I read through it. For me, the whittle down list would be:

1) Cella - my first soap and one I will aways have on hand.

2) Martin de Candre - I love everything about this soap

3). DR Harris soap - all three scents I have tried are great and the soap's performance is outstanding. Spin the scent wheel, they are all winners

[FlyingCostello]

MWF, DRH Arlington, Crabtree & Evelyn Sienna.

But I think it will change when my brick of Cella arrives later this week

[Saltchuck]

MWF
Institut Karite (or maybe Cade)
Cella

If Proraso Red comes out as a soap, the Cella might get bumped.

[Acmemfg]

C&E Nomad
Cella
Muhle Sea Buckthorn

La Toja Manantiales if they start making it ever again would take the #3 spot from Muhle

[gwav64]

This another one of those threads I enjoyed more as I read through it. For me, the whittle down list would be:

1) Cella - my first soap and one I will aways have on hand.

2) Martin de Candre - I love everything about this soap

3). DR Harris soap - all three scents I have tried are great and the soap's performance is outstanding. Spin the scent wheel, they are all winners

Well done!

[Le Buzz]

Don't even need 3, I'd be happy with just Cade. I love it that much.

[lordfink]

1) Pre de Provence
2) TABAC
3) DR Harris Marlborough

(MWF would have made it to #3 but it gives me in grown hair for some reason)

[sfcablecar]

Excluding vintage soaps, and noting that my mind will change tomorrow, today it would be:

- La Toja
- Martin de Candre
- D.R. Harris Arlington
- Czech & Speake Oxford & Cambridge

Wait, that's four . . . Oh well . . .

[Gingerbread]

Proraso Green
Col Conk Bay Rum
Strop Shoppe Black Tie

[LouieGrandie]

This another one of those threads I enjoyed more as I read through it. For me, the whittle down list would be:

1) Cella - my first soap and one I will aways have on hand.

2) Martin de Candre - I love everything about this soap

3). DR Harris soap - all three scents I have tried are great and the soap's performance is outstanding. Spin the scent wheel, they are all winners

This would be my three as well.

[Catalin]

1. MWF
2. MdC
3. Cella

[Sir Lurkalot]

Arko, VDH and MWF

[Beezerpuppy]

Mitchell Wool Fat
DR Harris Arlington
Proraso White tub

[Bill Smith]

My three must have soaps would be:

1) L'Occataine Cade
2) E-Shave Avocado and Linden
3) ?

[xraygun]

the 3 soaps I would have to have would be the following;























All of them.

[gwav64]

the 3 soaps I would have to have would be the following;























All of them.

Hmmmm.....

[celestino]

Mystic Water Soap (Bay Rum)
Mike's Natural Soaps

i don't even need any others as these two are fabulous!