My experience resembles a formula I've read before on the forum: Mild Razor + Mild Blade = Rough Shave, Mild Razor + Sharp Blade = Great Shave Of course YMMV applies here.
Derby's are considered to be on the mild side of blades. Feathers have a reputation for being the sharpest, ie the guillotine of blades. Astra's get a lot of love here, and fall in the middle somewhere...as do the Red Personna's. I'd encourage you to try the ones you've listed as well, but don't count any out. Stick with one, maybe the Reds since you've got no recollection of irriration, and hone your skills. Once you've used the same blade til you have no more (2 weeks or so) revisit some of the others. You may be surprised how one blade didn't work prior but does later. I was.
Personally, I get great shaves from Astra's, Gillette Blacks, Feathers, Lab Blues, SuperMax Super Plats...I'm not sure about the Feathers or Lab Blues, but 3 of those 5 are coated platinum which to me is a pattern. Derby's tore my face to shreds and I now use them as razor blades around my house for various tasks. Good Luck to you!
BOTOC - 2011 R41, PMJ, SOC 2-Band/Boar fan club; Noob Straight User.