Mama Bear's Iced Lime. Just used it this morning. Very nice soap... I've had it for about 3 years now with light use, but always enjoy the menthol kick and scent when I use it. Second place would be her Awakenings soap.
I really liked the scent of Mama Bear's Grape Fruit Ice and it had plenty of menthol, I mean freeze your face off menthol. I do favor Proraso however, more cooling than freezing. I like menthol but I like a cooling sensation, not a face freeze.
Old Fogie. It's not fer eatin', it's fer lookin' through.
QCS Vostok is the bomb. Almost unbearable.
Gonna throw SCS Blue Line into the fray. The soap doesn't produce a lather as cold as QCS Vostok but the moisturzing properties of the lather make it a real winner.
"Most men pursue pleasure with such breathless haste that they hurry past it."
Another vote for QCS Vostok. Absolute face freezer.
-- YTMR --
MB Lemon Ice and Proraso
arko stick smahed into a tub with watered down noxema, 3-4 tbs. of noxema. let air dry. cheap and superb.
but been dying to try the Vostok everyone raves about. awaiting my ogallala aftershave. I heard it stings!! yeah!
Suds and Sparkles Peppermint It's not menthol, but Peppermint Essential Oil.
Funny just posted about MB Ice.
I go with: Proraso as the regular and MB Awakenings for the occasional variety.
I would go with Iced Key Lime from QCS. Can't go wrong with Vostok or Proraso either. My favorite smelling, face cooling soap is without a doubt the new Iced Key Lime though.
+1 on the Vostok
+1 on iced key lime, especially since it's a limited time production run. Get it while you can!
In order of preference,
Mama Bears Rosemary Mint
Greg...Shaving,Cigars and Whiskey...It's "ME" Time