The thing about reviews are, and this goes for everything in general not just scents, is that people complain more than they compliment, and they compliment when they are blown away.
The best way to look into reviews and really glean good information, is not to pay attention to marketing buzzwords, and ignore the highest and lowest comments. The best reviews are the two, three, and four star reviews, where they point out what they didn't like and concede good points on the bad reviews, and point out the short comings on an otherwise good product on the good reviews.
Try to read as many as you can, so you can get a bit of wide perspective. This policy has worked for me for years doing online shopping.
[URL="http://www.twitter.com/StropShoppe"]Strop Shoppe[/URL] - Fine mens grooming and body products.
Find us at [URL]http://www.stropshoppe.com[/URL] or view my blog at [URL]http://www.stropshoppe.com/blog[/URL]