Which Eucaliptus-mint soap do you prefer?

[pipskicks]

Mentolipto in my opinion does not fit your bill, it is a very very mild scent. Excellent performing and not offensive smelling, but I would not describe it as eucalyptus/mint at all.

I would drop this soap in a second based on scent. It was PIFed to me and was my only soft soap and I think I will still continue to use it for it's productivity.

[lu20vt]

SMN,Dovo and Mike's

[petr]

I need to grab myself some Calani "ice angel" then. Although I will be surprised (and saddened) if it manages to knock SMN off of the top spot.

Calani is superb, yes, but SMN is still my very favorite of any product. SMN is simply a no fuss perfect shave every time - str8 or DE. My SMN ain't going anywhere. It's interesting to find something so different and effective though in the calani.

[jpipes3]

I recently traded for some Mentolipto, and I'm a fan. The scent is a bit sweeter than expected. I think it's perfectly fine. The performance is just ridiculous. I wish it had some menthol cooling to it, but it's a great soap to set up for a Proraso splash.