I found a great aftershave lotion that I've been using for the last couple of years: The Art of Shaving Lavender After Shave Balm. It is great for me. It doesn't sting, which is a problem for me and my very sensitive skin, my face usually doesn't hurt the next day (reevaluating that as I learn to use a DE, but at least my face doesn't hurt when using it after a straight razor shave), and my face remains moisturized for most of the rest of the day.
Only problem is each bottle costs about $36 each.
Can someone recommend an aftershave with similar results to this but less costly?