The Crew Moisturizing Shave Cream DOES NOT have the same aroma as their 'Classic' hair care line. Their moisturizing shave cream has a eucalyptus, with menthol, sage, and thyme oils mixed in. It is not the strong clove scent of their lubricating shave oil either. The moisturizing shave cream is brushless, and does not lather with a brush, although you can apply it with a brush, but it will not lather.
Originally Posted by jazzguy
Their classic fragrance cologne does have a similar aroma to their classic hair care line, but to me has more pronounced citrus and woodsy notes. I suppose you could spray a couple of spritzes into a fragrance-free soap or cream when whipping up your lather, and find out if it will match the scent of American Crew. Another thing to do is do add one or two drops of their daily shampoo, classic body wash, or their 3-In-One to your lather and see if that is what would work.
Have a great shave, and great day. - Troy