Aftershave and soap mixture.

I was thinking about getting the Art of Shaving sandlewood cream. What is a good aftershave or balm that would compliment?

AOS does have a sandalwood AS balm. I know if you get the pre-oil, too, they put it in a bundle (semi-) discount price. It is pricey compared to most everything else out there non-AOS, but it is good quality stuff (& it will last).