I'm a big fan of almost all the Nancy Boy products I've tried. The replenishing cream is one of my top three creams. I get great shaves from it and it leaves my face feeling really healthy.
I haven't tried the cooling gel because my skin is too sensitive for peppermint anything, but I actually do like the replenishing aftershave gel. I only find it sticky when I use too much. Today I used just a tiny bit, and it worked quite well. I'd recommend that anybody else trying that gel to use a lot less than you think you need - a little goes a long way.
I can also recommend a few of their other products: the mild facial cleanser is excellent, and so is the replenishing facial moisturizer (more of that cucumber smell, which I like, but not as strong a scent as with the aftershave gel.)
Joining their Club Nancy Boy saves you 15% on everything, all the time. Plus, they always have extra free stuff if you spend over $50.
Good company with fine customer service, too.
No anchovies? — you've got the wrong man. I spell my name "Danger"