Need some help from the collective wisdom out there, fellow B&Bers!
While I like nearly all of the shaving scents I've encountered so far in my two months of wet/DE shaving, my SWILTDDUP typically is not impressed. She prefers more "manly" scents - and here I think she is meaning typical modern colognes.
For example, Tabac smells like old grandma to her.
MWF was just soapy.
C&E Sienna was, meh.
Mystic Waters Coconut & Cella smelled like dessert.
Pinaud Clubman seemed too sweet.
CO Bigelow reminded her of medicine.
I am looking for a "perfect" cream and aftershave combo that ladies might consider to smell "manly." Any suggestions...?