I'm looking for an AS splash with citrusy top notes AND base notes. I've had very little luck finding something like this. Usually I find something with very agreeable and pleasant top notes, only to be let down with heavy base notes that disagree with my throat (and SWMBO). So I'm wondering if anyone knows of an aftershave splash that's citrusy on the top end and on the base end for extended wear. I like cedar notes a lot, and really don't like musk or heavy scents if that makes sense. Longevity would be nice, but I'm not looking for a cologne.

I've tried St. Lucia Citrocol Lime and that is quite possibly the fastest fleeting AS I've ever experienced—gone within 10 min without a trace.

What about 4711? Anyone have experience with this?