Lumiere Noire by MFK?

I like rose scents apparently as I own many of them all of a sudden (Windsor, Domenico Caraceni, Rose 31). I also recently got a decant of MFK APOM PH from Archfire, and though it isn't a rose I see that MFK also makes Lumiere Noire.

For a guy that loves Windsor, really likes DC1913, and thinks Rose 31 is only ok, where do you think I would stand with Lumiere Noire? I'm not looking for a rose scent just for the sake of a rose scent, but it gets good reviews and it seems MFK does some good work as evidenced by the APOM experience.

This is another one of the MFK samples that I picked up and am still looking forward to trying.

Lumiere Noire Pour Homme is on the Rose 31 side of Roses versus the darker 88 or DC1913. I go back and forth on 31 and LNPH as to which I like better, but personally I think they are both fantastic.