Oriscent - ​Pink Papua
I've been curious about this one and you're great review has convinced me that I need to sample Turtle Vetiver! How does it compare to other vetiver frags?
Of the ones you mentioned I am only familiar with Route de Vetiver, and Malle's Vetiver. One of the reviews that you quoted mentioned the "smokey" character of vetiver. When I think smoky vetiver I think Encre Noir and L'Occitane Vetyver. At the moment I prefer a smokier vetiver scent but that'll change as we get warmer weather up here in the Pacific NW.