My GF really loves Burberry Brit on me ... "there is nothing to compare!" Now, I like B-Brit too, but I think what really gets her interested is it's the cologne I was wearing in the first few weeks when we started dating ... so it has some very powerful positive memories associated with it.
Perhaps Hugo casts a similar spell in your case.
Maybe the best thing to do is not find a similar replacement, but find a new cologne and wear it during some great events leading to some great memories for her. That way, you can start up with the new cologne of your choice, and (hopefully) she'll come around.
Be there or be square. Only I can do both!
I've got a cat named Beefeater and a dog named Beefeater, and two goldfish called Beefeater and Beefeater. There's Beefeater my hamster and Beefeater my horse, and my piglet, known as Beefeater of course.
Veteran of the Great Irisch Moos Campaign of 2008-09