Time to resurrect this thread as I just finished my sampler pack tonight. My lasting impression, many lovely scents, excellent quality lather, and YMMV could not be better represented.
My favorite: Trafalgar by a nose over Grafton. I loved both these scents and would rate them equally; however, the lady of the house thought Grafton a bit too rosy. Trafalgar on the other hand was spicy woods with maybe a hint of white flower (but I'm no expert). A tub of this will be headed my way.
Next tier were the surprises. I really liked the Almond. A sweet but clean almond scent. Also liked Ultimate Comfort quite a bit with its clean, subtle scent. I wasn't expecting to like either of these, especially the almond. Now I want to sample some other almond scents to compare.
Biggest (only) disappointment was WI Lime. I tend to like lime and citrus scents and was fully expecting to love this. Alas, it was not to be. Maybe Castle Forbes will be the next stop on the search for a good lime scent.
So here are my rankings: Trafalgar > Grafton > Almond > UC > 1805 > Sandalwood > Rose > Lavender > WI Limes.
Last edited by Patman27; 06-06-2012 at 08:32 PM.
Reason: Forgot Lavender
'Absorb what is useful; Discard what is not; Add what is uniquely your own.'