Help me match my cologne - Polo Big Pony #1

[OldeSchool]

Fellow shavers and scentaholics alike, I come to you for some help.

Currently in my rotation (and my most favorite scent) is my Polo Big Pony #1 cologne. I'm looking for a shaving cream that has a similar scent. My go-to shave cream is Truefitt & Hill: 1805. I can't stop using this stuff as its amazing, but lately I've decided to try to find a shave cream / face balm that better compliments my current choice in colognes.

An amateur description of PBP#1: Sporty, citrusy with a very mild musk undertone. This could also be described as a slightly more mature smelling (musky) professional smelling Tommy Sport.

I don't have any great shaving vendors near me so I can't go and smell all the great products out there. I am brave enough, however, to order a few things suggested by my fellow members.

Thanks for your replies.

[michiganlover]

Is it really necessary to match your shaving cream with your cologne? I have never had the scent of shaving cream linger around after the shave. It's usually gone within 5 minutes.

The one notable exception to this, was AOS Sandalwood which I could smell for at least a good hour afterwards.

[joshuasethcomposer]

Can't go wrong with unscented.