Pick for me...

[ikeyballz]

Now I know scents are extremely YMMV, but based on my likes and dislikes what do you guys recommend?

Listed from liked the most to ehhh:

1) VDH Deluxe (Gray flannel?)
2) Palmolive
3) Cella
4) DR. Harris Arlington


I know, its strange - I seem to have it backwards : I think I actually like the scent of "soap" which is why the palmolive and VDH get higher places than the others...

I don't MIND the scent of arlington, its actually growing on my slightly as I use it daily, but I dont feel the "clean barbershop" scent that the VDH gives me.

[gash]

If you like clean, soapy scents, try Institut Karite.

[Marco]

Both Cella and Harris Arlington!

[Fozz7769]

All of the mentioned plus La Toja.

[PozzSka]

Institut Karite
Pre de Provence
MWF

all have "soapy" scents to me, but they all smell different as well.

[maxman]

Scent wise I'd go Cella.
I can't get enough of the smell of that stuff.

[Obiwan]

Cella

[Gwhunter]

As much as I like Cella it is not a scent I would consider soapy. Almondy?, yes. Soapy? Ehhhh....