So my birthday is coming around soon, and I'm considering asking for another bottle of scotch to add to my ever expanding collection. Here's what I'm considering:
Johnnie Walker Gold
Ardbeg Alligator (assuming I can get my hands on it, I'm an Ardbeg member so there's a chance)
HP 18 year old
Quite a tough choice. I'm a huge fan of the HP12 and all reports I've read on the 18 are phenomenal. I had a dram of Talisker at a restaurant a few months back and found it delicious. Ardbeg Alligator is intriguing (and I enjoy the 10 y.o.) and JW Gold has alot of great reviews too. What are your experiences with these and what are your thoughts?