Alright Veg, you win

I had to give this a shot and it was not great from the start. I have been reading about this stuff for a long time and tried all the tricks and it barely changed. I put it in a glass bottle and kept it open on the cabinet for a week and it still smells like cat pee. I guess I wasn't chosen.

Either that, or the cats in your neighborhood are particularly classy animals.

You know what? I'm a big Pinaud fan but I could never get used to the Veg either.

See if you can find Pinaud's Classic Vanilla. I've used Clubman for about 30 years, but I got some Classic Vanilla at Merz in Chicago recently, and I have been reaching for it about twice as often as the Clubman.

I've gotten some compliments on it, too!

I have all the other Pinaud aftershaves except the Lime Sec. I LOVE the Vanilla, as well as all the others. I think the special reserve might be my favorite, though.