I've only tried the Col Conk Bay Rum and Ogalalla Bay Rum with Sandalwood.
Personally, I like the Conk, it has more sting to it and I like the sharp smell. But, I probably won't buy it again. SWMBO compliments the Ogalalla whenever she smells it and does not like the smell of the Conk. The Ogalalla has less sting to it, is a more complex smell and has more goodies in for your face - just remember to shake it everytime before using.
Razors don't shave people. People shave people!
There are three critical types of moments in life: Times when we should use opportunity to be enamoured with finer details, and times we should ignore the minutia.