Wilkinson sword stick VS Palmolive stick

IMO the Palmolive stick is much better than the Wilkie stick, I didn't like the Wilkie scent - too synthetic and the lather wasn't as good for me as regards protection and spost-shave feel (I have hard water in my area if that makes a difference?).

I did have a strange skin reaction to the Wilkie stick, but even if I hadn't, I wouldn't bother with the stick again.