Gillette New Help, Otto Roth

I have acquired these three new types over time, and the middle razor's head is baffling me. The comb doesnt curl over like the other two, and the cap does not arch as high. Is this the correct head?

Also - has anyone tried the slim version? To my delight this one was stamped by Mr. Otto Roth. Any preference between the two?

The center razor is a short comb, the other two are long combs. I prefer the long comb

I too prefer Long Comb News over Short Comb.

Here is a slim Long Comb that I own but it is stamped Gillette.


Also, here is an image of some of the handles that came with New/New Deluxe heads.

Well, I will be the first to chime in and say I prefer the short comb.