I think this question has been asked here before, but what colognes have a similar scent to the regular Clubman aftershave. I think someone said that Canoe was close.
Thoughts?
Thoughts?
Colognes similar to Clubman
- Thread starter DutchMagnus
- Start date
This just very recently came up and I'm pretty sure Canoe was the far and away most recommended.
I usually don't wear another scent when I'm in da club...
I usually don't wear another scent when I'm in da club...
Mama Bear's barbershop cologne is somewhat close. It's a very powdery barbershop type scent.
Brut has always reminded me somewhat of Clubman.
I got a haircut in the barbershop yesterday, and, as always, my barber slapped what I had always assumed was Clubman on me after shaving my neck. This time I happened to get a quick glance of the bottle and it wasn't Clubman! I didn't get a good enough look to tell what it was. Is there another mainline barbershop product that smells like Clubman? Perhaps a Stephens or Masters product?
I got a haircut in the barbershop yesterday, and, as always, my barber slapped what I had always assumed was Clubman on me after shaving my neck. This time I happened to get a quick glance of the bottle and it wasn't Clubman! I didn't get a good enough look to tell what it was. Is there another mainline barbershop product that smells like Clubman? Perhaps a Stephens or Masters product?
Coty Musk
Penhaligon's Racquets
take some Clubman and put it in an atomiser.. 
Should have asked.. some say Master's "Lord and Master" is close. I had a barber use it on me once and it is in the same ballpark.. seems like a little more spicy.. that was almost 2 years ago though..
There is a Lustray "Coachman" that is supposed to be nearly the same but weaker.. I believe Lustray is also made by Pinaud..
Avon Wild Country is very similar to Clubman also. Vintage is slightly better than modern.
Just use MORE clubman !! That stuff is strong enough to last.
Canoe and Coty Musk are almost exact duplicates of Clubman. They must all use the same base ingredient.
Another vote for Brut and Avon Wild Country.
Canoe all the way.
Possibly, but Sartorial is much closer to my nose.
Royal Copenhagen bears some striking resemblance. Musk for men by Coty also. But in the scheme of things, the only one that captures that fresh-from-the-barbershop smell is Clubman.
...
...
Although not real similiar Rive Gauche does the barbershop thing almost as good as Clubman...
Thanks. I'll have to ask next time. It is possible, I guess, that it is the Lustray you reference.
Clubman always reminds me of Brut.
