Cyril R. Salters French Vetiver SC and Taylors Rose...depending on how you look at it.
I've never tried Tabac, but hear nothing but good things - one question...what does it actually smell like...and is it a strong scent that sticks around?
I believe that Penhaligon's makes a Blenheim Bouquet cream ... that'd be pretty manly. I know they make the shave soap.
Musgo Real. More so than Trumpers Sandalwood, I think.
Nothing beats this for a "manly scent":