SO I currently have two products labelled Bay Rum, but they don't smell even remotely like each other. One is the Ogallala Bay Rum aftershave, which to me smells like eggnog which then fades to clove. The other is Mama Bear's bay rum soap, which is much more herbal smelling, and much less sweet. Strangely, neither smells much like rum. I was curious if anyone has experience with both or either, and could give me a sense of which was closer to what people think of when they think bay rum.