I just got a bottle of Thayers Rose petal witch Hazel stuff from Westcoast shaving and I have to say it works like a charm. My issue here is the scent, to me it doesn't smell like roses at all it just has some sort of perfumy smell. Am I the only one who feels this way? I'm reading the rieviews for this stuff and everyone seems to love it. I was also interested the purchasing a puck of the GEO Trumpers rose soap, but if it smells anything like the Witch Hazel I may just go for another scent. What do you guys think?