Now that Proraso isn't at Target anymore (glad I put off buying new proraso ASB for so long because "it's always there"...now it's gone) I am in need of a similarly-priced, similarly-performing ASB.
I have only tried Proraso and nivea ASBs. I preferred the proraso for scent and I found it left my skin feeling less greasy compared to the nivea (but Nivea wasn't that bad, just not as good as proraso IMHO). I have also tried the burt's bees bay rum ASB, but found it didn't seem to perform as well as the two above-mentioned ones.
Now the question is, I know I can still order proraso ASB online, but now might be a good time to try some new ones (in the same price range). You can vote for the choices and/or you can write in suggestions. Any input would be welcomed.