George, which 30mm did you get from Seth? His STA?
If so, I think you'll find the comparison to my STA Rudy Vey to be about what you'll experience. They are both great. I found the RV softer but less bristle action. The MF had more action but feels WAY smaller on your face.
By the way, the 30mm MF I saw pics of looked even more bulb shaped than my 28mm. IMO, neither will feel as large as the STA.
Also, for an update, the MF took on the Stubby 3 today. Way more different than I'd expected. Both are very soft but the MF has lots more backbone. Much scrubbier and actually felt smaller on the face than the shorter, narrower Stubby. Very interesting.
Ken
Rooney 3/3 Finest, MdC, iKon OSS with Med Preps, AOS AS balm
I got a response from Lee and the largest he has right now is a 25 x 53 so I think I will pass. I have a 25mm presently in a TGN Finest.
I expect that the MF would be considerably denser than the TGN but I am really looking forward to something around 28mm.
Sigh, the story of my life.
George
This so funny.
I got a 2nd e-mail from Lee and he has (had) the exact brush as Ken has and he was keeping it as a spare.
Well, his SWMBO "suggested" that he sell it to me, and TADA, it's on its way.
I guess SWMBOism transcends oceans and cultures.
I can hardly wait.
George
Damnit, I had resisted these brushes thus far, but real horn was the tipping point. I'm $125 poorer and I have a handpicked Blond Badger en route.
-Ian S.
Imho, these are so nice it makes me wonder why I keep my other 15-20 brushes. It will be interesting to see if others are equally enthusiastic.![]()
I have to say this brush is growing on me daily...It is breaking down very nicely and the tips are becoming silky soft.
I'm now on the fence on whether I prefer this one to the Rooney 1XL. I have the White Handle 24mm/54mm.
After using for the first 2-3 times, I have to say the brush felt a bit prickly and too stiff and was thinking about selling. With use, now the knot feels full, soft and dense. This is what I was hoping Simpson two band would be.
Warning: do not judge this brush until you use it at least 10 times.
Last edited by AJMiami; 02-01-2011 at 02:09 PM.
- AJ -
Good to hear, AJ!
I'm already loving mine. It's gonna get even better?Closer to my sweet spot?
Ken
Rooney 3/3 Finest, MdC, iKon OSS with Med Preps, AOS AS balm
Guys, I passed on our good wishes to Lee and his wife and he asked me to express his thanks.
So here it is.
Consider yourselves expressed.![]()
George
A bit of eye candy.....The high quality of the hair and knot can be seen here
CIMG6537.jpg
CIMG6545.JPG M&F.jpg
- AJ -
If these were sold in a 24mm knot and 48mm loft I would be all over it. They do look great though...
~Joe~
I believe Lee mentioned that he was using vintage Rooney knot shaping forms, and I would suspect he is proud of that fact, so I doubt you'll see a knot shape change in the near future. Though maybe that was for his 3 band brushes and not the M&F's.
Really, the whole anti-bulb thing is a bit overblown. A few guys got pissed at Simpson for making so many bulbs, a few more added off hand that they preferred fans, and suddenly fans are the new black. Don't get me wrong, I love the fan shape of my stubby or my UK silvertip knots.... but I also love the bulb of my chubby, my TGN SuperSilvertip, and even my super-bulb'ed 2 band duke.
I don't think 48mm is too low for a 2 band bulb... it all depends on personal preference, and I think a lot of people would prefer 48mm to 54mm for a bulb shaped 2 band. I can't speak for everyone though.
-Ian S.
Lee told me he is using the original M&F cannons for the M&F knots.
I too think that with the soft tips of this hair, a sub 50mm loft bulb would be just fine. The Simpson two bands dont have the soft tips these do, so they feel much more pointy. My 50mm bulb is nice and soft on the face, so I double taking even 5mm off of it would be a huge problem. If you cut the loft down any more than the mid 40's though I would opt for a fan in a heartbeat.
Last edited by Loric; 02-02-2011 at 05:00 PM.
"Loric=Ernest Shackleton of SBAD" - Krona Kruiser
Bookmarks