AOS and MWF. I have other tallow soaps but more testing is required before I make a final judgment on them. 
Your Favorite Tallow-Based Soap?
- Thread starter direwolf1980
- Start date
AoS is about as good as they come these days, but I was recently gifted some C&S #88 by our site's ambassador. Holy moly!
For further details, you can meet me at the blood bank, where I'll be selling my eighth pint of blood.
For further details, you can meet me at the blood bank, where I'll be selling my eighth pint of blood.
WMF and honorable mention to AOS
AoS is about as good as they come these days, but I was recently gifted some C&S #88 by our site's ambassador. Holy moly!
For further details, you can meet me at the blood bank, where I'll be selling my eighth pint of blood.
C&S is that good? Save me a place in line.
Witchell's Moose Fat?
The Arko shave stick - no questions asked.
PC Tallow soap, unscented with added Menthol.
Harris Sandlewood - followed by Harris Almond, then Arlington.
Harris Sandlewood - followed by Harris Almond, then Arlington.
Prairie Creations (tallow, no lanolin) is my go-to soap. I always know what kind of lather I'm getting with that one, and I get great shaves.
That said, I also love my Palmolive stick and AOS Lemon, and both of them lather up a little easier than PC IMHO.
Still, I reach for that puck of PC at least 3 times a week...
That said, I also love my Palmolive stick and AOS Lemon, and both of them lather up a little easier than PC IMHO.
Still, I reach for that puck of PC at least 3 times a week...
Mwf.
TOBS Sandalwood
Arko stick
Williams
Palmolive
Arko stick
Williams
Palmolive
Arko
Cella, Crema Sapone Extra Extra Purissima
P-160
AOS
David
P-160
AOS
David
1. Tabacstick
2. Palmostick
3. Simstick (Sir Irisch Moos)
Yeah!!!
2. Palmostick
3. Simstick (Sir Irisch Moos)
Yeah!!!
I'm with Ouch. The Czech & Speake soaps are incredible
AOS Lavender 
HAHAHA!!! Moose fat!
Tabac for me. Admttedly, though, it's the only tallow based soap I've used. Really can't see myself trying anything else (besides Cella maybe) given the price
erformance ratio.
Last edited:
MWF and DR Harris - all flavours
I agree MWF and the entire line of DR Harris, I also have to add all the offerings of AOS, I characterize AOS as a heavier soap, but I don't find myself favoring any of these three great soaps.
I do love Tabac, but I just used Palmolive today for the first time and all I can say is WOW!
