I mix alcohol and non-alcohol after-shave treatments and don't have any issues. There is a school of thought (which I subscribe to) that alcohol is a necessary part of the post-shave process. I don't know why a product would say to not use with alcohol-based aftershaves, honestly.
Having said that, it's your skin. If your skin after a shave feels smooth, moisturized, and non-irritated, then you are doing the right thing by it.
David [URL="http://badgerandblade.com/vb/showthread.php?t=12450"]Hall O'Fame[/URL]
[I]Buddy Love:[/I] You're crazy about me, right? And I can understand it. Only this morning, looking in the mirror before shaving, I enjoyed seeing what I saw so much I couldn't tear myself away. Have some, baby?[/SIZE]