Pyrat XO
Bacardi 8 Anos
Don't be put off just because Bacardi is a mega brand.
Appleton Estate
If you like a heavy rum, Pampero Aniversario is a good one. But my favorite is one I found when I was in San Juan: Barrilito Three Star. Unfortunately, it is difficult to find in my area.
I'll try some this week. Any specific recommendations?DE, seeing as you're in Ontario, try some of the Cuban rums at the LCBO. Excellent to drink straight, and make a mojito to die for.