Trumpers Rose or Trumpers Violet?

[Obsessed]

Which do you guys prefer? I don't seem to read as much about the violet.

(Yes, contrary to my earlier thread, AOS has not managed to defeat my SSAD! )

[thunderball]

Had it and didn't care for it much. I say rose but don't listen to me.

[beginish]

I love both the violet and rose, but prefer violet. If you haven't tried it before, see if you can nab a sample of the cream from Trumpers. I find the soap and cream scents to be equivalent.

[Barbash]

I love both the violet and rose, but prefer violet. If you haven't tried it before, see if you can nab a sample of the cream from Trumpers. I find the soap and cream scents to be equivalent.

+1 on the samples. You can even request that they include both the Rose and Violet.

I also prefer the Violet, but thats just because I am not a big Rose fan.

[kingfisher]

I don't like the scent of the violet, so Rose for me.

[BigRich]

There are several good roses out there but I think Violet is Trumpers' stand out scent. It's one of my all time favorite creams.

[Dandaman]

I have both and I prefer the Rose. The Violet was at first an overpowering, sickly sweet fragrance. It has settled down since and I can use it now, but I still prefer the Rose.

[ackvil]

I like the lime and almond better.

[ouch]

Rose.

[Austin]

I like both but have been using violet the past week. I really like violet.

[LinuxMintyFresh]

Violet for me. The rose smells too false, or something. The violet cream smells like fresh cut flowers. You should get the samples, however, and make up your own mind. I have a feeling that the responses to this query will be fairly evenly split.

[media]

I've read before that the violet cream can dye your silvertip permanently purple.

[Iakona]

It wouldn't surprise me if the violet stains (permanent or not) - the rose stained my boar but I haven't really looked to see if it is coming out.
That said, I really enjoy the subtle scent of the violet soap. Rose is good, but violet is more toned down and natural smelling.

[ouch]

I've read before that the violet cream can dye your silvertip permanently purple.

The most dye-laden product I can recall is the old formula Harris lavender cream. I have towels that are purple despite five years' worth of laundering.

[Confilo]

All Roses for me, but i'll revisit Violet

[Vlad]

Just got my Rose. I LOVE IT.

[Empty Words]

I prefer the Rose by far.

[Mpugh77]

Rose followed by some Victorian Rose AS milk from TSD or some Coral skin food.

[beginish]

I've read before that the violet cream can dye your silvertip permanently purple.

Before I succumbed to SSAD and SCAD, I used the violet cream exclusively for a year, and it had no effect on the color of the one brush I was using.

[media]

Before I succumbed to SSAD and SCAD, I used the violet cream exclusively for a year, and it had no effect on the color of the one brush I was using.

Thanks for clearing that up!