I have to give a sincere recommendation for Dermalogica's Post-Shave Balm. After a great DE shave with my favorite shaving cream (like TOBS Lavender or T&H Trafalgar), one squeeze of this post-shave treatment is like nothing else I've ever used. It's sort of clear and leaves no residue. It absorbs completely and perfectly. The scent is mild and pleasing. The company (Dermalogica) is well-respected for their extremely simple but healthy and pure products.
It's on the spendy side, but a very little goes a very long way! Definitely give it a shot, particularly if you have sensitive skin.