Taylor's Herbal Pre-Shave a strange product...
First just wanted to say hello to everyone again... I've been so busy with life and work (and my now expecting wife ) that I haven't had much chance to jump on here lately...
Anyway, back on topic... I wanted to take a moment to talk about Taylor's herbal pre-shave gel...
A long time back Michael (aka LeisureGuy) was polite enough to donate a jar of this to me. I had replied in a post about pre-shaves, and mentioned that I had never tried it. Michael told me he had a jar and he had never really cared for it. Next thing I know, it showed up in the mail for me. (Thanks again!)
I have used this many time since, and finally feel like I can give a pretty accurate description of it, and the description is... Well.... Odd... Let me explain...
I'm a pretty die-hard Proraso pre-shave fan. In fact, other then the taylors, it's currently the only thing (other then normal hair conditioner) that I've used. It seems to work really well (especially if applied in the shower).
Back on track with the Taylors... The first time I used this stuff I think my impression was "Terrible" Regardless, I still had a good shave so it wasn't a total loss...
A few days later I tried again... Nope, this stuff was still terrible. Let me explain what I mean by terrible. When you use the Proraso, you can physically feel how much softer the whiskers get. With the Taylor's, you couldn't feel any difference at all. It creates a sort of "film" (feels like glycerin) on your face, but that's about it. Just terrible... Yet again I managed to get a good shave, so again, not a total loss...
The next try was the same... But once again I got a great shave, so at least... wait... wha? huh? Is this a coincidence?
EVERY single time I used this stuff, it felt like it wasn't doing anything at all, yet I couldn't ignore the fact that each and every time I got a terrific shave... Hrmmmm...
Maybe the glycerin content? So I tried using glycerin in place of it... Nope... That wasn't it... Proraso was certainly far better then the glycerin... In fact, the glycerin (using it only as a pre-shave and nothing else) were the worst shaves I've ever had...
I couldn't explain what I was seeing, so I did test after test... Constantly and consistantly I was getting better shaves with the Taylor's DESPITE the seemingly little to no effect it had on softening my whiskers...
I still can't explain it, but I've done numerous tests over and over and they've proved out time and time again.
So if you haven't tried this stuff, it's worth a shot... If you have tried it, try to pay attention to the shave, not it's affect on your whiskers.
As always your experience may differ, but I've grown to really love this stuff.
Interesting review. I've been looking to add a few Taylor's products to my shaving line up anyway and the herbal pre-shave might just find it's way onto that list. I'll do some digging around and see if my normal sources carry it.
Lately those trouble spots on the sides of my throat have been acting difficult with everything short of a straight razor or a slantbar w/ a Feather blade. I know I could just stick with those two approaches and be done with it but half the fun of wet shaving is experimenting with all the great products.
P.S. Congratulations on the upcoming baby!
How does the Herbal pre-shave gel compare to the pre-shave oil?
I dunno... I've never tried the oil... Was always afraid it would gum up my brush.
If you had to choose one - the Taylor's or the Proraso - which would it be?
Choose one?!? This is shaving man! We buy everything!!!
Seriously? hrmmm.... That's really a tough question. Like I said, I can't in any way shape or form deny the results I've seen with the Taylor's, yet the Proraso also gives great results and well... It just has that something special... Maybe it's the cooling tingle of the euclyptus?
I'll put it to you this way... On the mornings when I wake up late, or got a shower before bed and don't intend to take one in the morning, I usually go for the Taylor's. I can rub a little in, and by the time my lather is ready I'm good to go.
On mornings when I take a shower, I always grab the Proraso. If you haven't slathered this stuff on your face while in a hot shower, it's quite an experience to say the least.
I've had this product for a while and have used it numerous times but I never could see a difference in my shave. IMO it is too expensive. I've had better results with the Proraso.
How do you apply the Taylor gel. To a dry or wet face? I've tried several different methods but nothing seemed to work.
By Jcof3474 in forum Aftershaves
Last Post: 02-24-2010, 04:49 PM
vBulletin Security provided by