I have recently acquired and used two new soaps: Mitchell's Woolfat and Honeybee Bay Rum. Both of these soaps are really high quality a provide a high quality shave and a pleasurable experience. I find the Honeybee's soap to be very moisturizing. So much so that I don't have to use any aftershave on my face with it. I also find this to be true of the Woolfat (when properly mixed) provides a perfect amount of moisture to my face.
Overall I think they are both worth investing in (especially the Mitchell's with the cool dish). I do not think however that one is not that much better than the other so if you don't want the dish go with the honeybee's. In fact I find that most of the stuff I have tried compares fairly evenly overall, but for some reason I keep wanting to experiment with new creams and new soaps.
I will have to shave with both some more times to get a more concrete opinion but as of now I like both equally.