I can admit I have a small addiction to after shaves (who here doesn't ). Within my selection I find that they all have a place in my heart, but this is not always true with the "wives/girlfriends". Different strokes for different folks I guess. I will say that even if I like a scent the "wife/girlfriend" test is the most important in my book, as it lends itself to other bonuses .
Mine go as follows:
-Old Spice (Shultton, P&G)
-Barbasol Pacific Rush
-Pinaud Bay Rum
So the real question is, which scents do you have that have passed the test?