There is one locally owned shop in town. They are Columbus Barber Shop Supply. They carry tons of lotions, older more traditional after shaves. They have all types of razors-starights, DE's, Mach 3's, etc. Basically any shaving item you could want except certain brands they can have. If anyone is in the Central Ohio are their info follows:
800-282-1272
614-299-4000
800-282-1272
614-299-4000