Similar Scents: Trafalgar and St. James?

[thehenbarris]

I recently picked up a tub of Trafalgar shaving cream and compared it to my St. James tub and wow are they similar. I'm wondering if the cologne scents are similar as well. I don't own either now but I'd much much rather pay the price of a bottle of St. James over a bottle of Trafalgar (75 is just too much to spend on a flying guess :smile:)

[michaelskar]

I really love both scents...but I don't think they're too similar.

[OldSchoolYoungin]

Totally subjective, but I don't feel they're too similar either. The St. James is great, no doubt, but to me the St. James is a "cleaner" scent. The Trafalgar is the distinguished Cedar and Sandalwood, beautifully done.

[Isaias]

How similar is the cream of St. James to the Cologne? I really like the cream maybe it is the one I like the most (Of course I have not tried a lot of creams)