Mixing Bay Rum

[Stan-The-Man]

This morning I was almost out of my three bottles of bay rum aftershave lotion. DOMINIAC, ROYALL and CLUBMAN so as any cheap person would do I mixed all three together thinking that being all bay rum aroma with only a slight differance it would be alright. Boy, was I ever wrong in plain English it turned into trash. Funny three nice products all a little differant but when mixed together it turned into a real foul smell. :frown: :frown:

Stanley

[billyjeff2]

Bet it smelled a bit like the bay?

[roughrider]

That sucks. Are you sure you don't have to let it age? :biggrin:

[Stan-The-Man]

It smelled like the deodorant like they use in the bars in Boston, real bad.:eek: :eek: :eek: :eek: :frown: :frown: :frown:

Stanley

[bladerunner]

I mixed a small amount oF Caswell-Masseys Michelsen's Bay Rum, and a small amount of Burts Bee Bay rum in a 6 oz bottle of Pianud's Bay Rum and it came out nice.

[Stan-The-Man]

Well, for me it turned out three good products equels one bad product.

I'm sure one of you who is a professor can work out a formular for this.

3 good =1 bad:eek: :eek:

Stanley

[xcubbies]

If I can hijack this thread, I like bay rum aftershave; it's traditional and simple. I'm currently about halfway through a bottle of Royall, but I'm not sure it is really worth its premium price. What's the thinking here about other bay rums on the market?

[Stan-The-Man]

I think CLUBMAN Bay Rum is very good, nice aroma and is very cheap.

Royall bay rum is only so so.

Don't do what I did and mix differant brands together, It does not work out.:c17:

[xcubbies]

I could have warned you, Stan. My mother use to mix together ice cream to save space in the refrigerator when the containers were getting low. It never works; certainly doesn't add up to the sum of the parts. Thanks for the advice on Clubman.