PDA

View Full Version : Welcome back, Soap!



Lynchmeister
04-12-2007, 10:07 AM
Well I'm happy to report that I've welcomed soaps back into my shaving fold. For the longest time I just could not figure them out despite all of the suggestions here. I attributed my past failures to poor water quality (read: hard), but now I think it was due to my lathering technique. I'm positive that it wasn't a poorly primed brush, because I would literally beat the hell out of the brush and soap.

In my past attempts, I would follow the typical soap lathering process of soaking brush, a little water on the soap, prime the brush a lot over the lather bowl to catch the drip, and then move to the bowl where I would whip out a very good looking, but poor performing lather. It would deteriorate and dry out on my face before I was halfway through my first pass. After a few times of this, I simply put the soaps away and gave up.

A few weeks ago, I read a thread by Ead, where he was describing similar problems in his quest for getting a good shave from a soap. A couple days later he reported success. I also read a theory that by whipping the lather in the bowl, you were beating more air into it, which would decrease the lubricity of the lather. Made sense to me. More air equals less water, right? This was enough for me to give the soap at least another shot.

This morning I brought out my QED Lemon and Cedarwood soap and followed the above routine, but instead of moving to a bowl, I went straight to the face, occasionally dipping the brush in hot water to keep things wet. I also employed another trick that has helped me with creams. I hold the brush in my left hand and my razor in the right so that I can periodically relather mid-pass. This has greatly improved the quality, quantity, and moisture of the lather on my face as I shave.

I finished the whole thing off with the alum block, a few spritzes of witch hazel, a splash of Aqua Velva, and a schmear of QED Texas Cedarwood EO skin conditioner. Very nice indeed!

Dennis
04-12-2007, 10:14 AM
This is why shave sticks are one of my favorite ways to make lather. If I have a loose puck, I hold the puck in my hand and prime the brush with it, then rub the soap all over my face ala a shave stick.

Dennis

Hurling Frootmig
04-12-2007, 12:13 PM
I find what works best for me is to:

1) Soak the brush
2) Put some hot water on the soap
3) Shower for about 10 minutes
4) Shake out the brush
5) Dump the water off the soap
6) Grab some cream (just kidding)
6) Really load up the brush and do it over the shaving bowl
7) Start to whip up the lather
8) If the lather seems to be whipping up normally I put the brush back on the soap. I basically want to have a mixture that I have to add water to in order to build later.
9) Apply to face

I was about to give up on C&E Sandalwood before hitting on this.

Lynchmeister
04-12-2007, 01:24 PM
I find what works best for me is to:

1) Soak the brush
2) Put some hot water on the soap
3) Shower for about 10 minutes
4) Shake out the brush
5) Dump the water off the soap
6) Grab some cream (just kidding)
6) Really load up the brush and do it over the shaving bowl
7) Start to whip up the lather
8) If the lather seems to be whipping up normally I put the brush back on the soap. I basically want to have a mixture that I have to add water to in order to build later.
9) Apply to face

I was about to give up on C&E Sandalwood before hitting on this.

In a bowl?

flippantfig
04-12-2007, 03:25 PM
I read your post and was interested in the approach. I have stayed away from my Trumpers pucks for many of the same reasons you gave for soap.

This evening I soaked the brush, got the puck wet and applied it straight to the face, whipped up over a bowl (and in it for a bit) then I went to the face with the brush to finish the lather.

Best lather I have had for a long time with soap! I'm sure its the puck-to-face bit that made the real difference! :biggrin:

Lynchmeister
04-12-2007, 05:45 PM
I read your post and was interested in the approach. I have stayed away from my Trumpers pucks for many of the same reasons you gave for soap.

This evening I soaked the brush, got the puck wet and applied it straight to the face, whipped up over a bowl (and in it for a bit) then I went to the face with the brush to finish the lather.

Best lather I have had for a long time with soap! I'm sure its the puck-to-face bit that made the real difference! :biggrin:

I would have loved to try this, but of course Charles pours directly into the jar and my one and only other soap, which was a puck, has since been melted down to fit the jar. The first chance I get, be it puck or shave stick, I'm definately gonna give it a shot.

I'm truly happy to hear that I might have played a part (however small it may be) in improving your results with your soap(s). Thinking back, I was this close to giving up on soaps completely...would have been a real shame considering all those great scents out there on offer to us!

ead
04-13-2007, 01:21 AM
I will tell you more about what I love in soaps
While creams DOES give me a better thick lather, the shave is different
When shaving with a soap I can get a very close shave, with cream it is harder, the cream just create a thick layer that prevent me from getting into the smallest hair

So
It is all a matter of taste, but I do love soaps and creams now :wink:

Lynchmeister
04-13-2007, 06:53 AM
Yes, I definately did notice a closer shave with the soap. It was a different sensation during the shave and I did give myself one tiny nick, but overall, I was very pleased with the shave.