The Ultimate Shave Off, Part II [Archive]

DunEdinRanger

06-26-2010, 05:26 PM

Last year, I decided to compare different razors, and post about the experience, Here is the thread: http://badgerandblade.com/vb/showthread.php?t=99005

I figured it might be interesting to do it again, but with some different razors.

This year, I have the DE89L, made by Edwin Jagger, and the Open Comb Micromatic. I will include the Barber Pole versions of the Slant and Open Comb razors. I am probably going to include a vintage Gillette or two.

I am going to start on July 1st with the Micromatic, and if anyone wants to join in, they are welcome to.

1. GEM Open Comb Micromatic (Ted Pella PTFE)
2. 1912 type GEM (Ted Pella PTFE)
3. Merkur Barber Pole Open Comb (12C) (Red Personna)
4. Edwin Jagger DE89L (Feather)
5. Gillette Tuckaway (Derby)
6. Gillette Red Tip TTO (Astra)
7. Gillette SLIM Adjustable (Astra)
8. Merkur Futur (Dorco ST 301)
9. Merkur Barber Pole Slant Bar razor. (Red Personna)
10. Schick Injector

You might be thinking, why not use the same make of blade throughout? The answer, at least in my case, is that I have found some blades work better in some razors than others.

brianw

06-26-2010, 05:46 PM

I would Lou but I couldn't get by 1,2 and 10...and I have to throw the straights in

DunEdinRanger

06-27-2010, 03:45 AM

Join in whatever "weeks" you can. :thumbup1:

The reason weeks is in quotes, is that I am also going to push the blades.

flight567

06-27-2010, 04:35 PM

can you add a merkur HD or a Gillette tech? (that's all i have) unless you are willing to PIF me one of the above razors lol (jk)

DunEdinRanger

06-27-2010, 06:55 PM

If I had any of those razors, I would throw them in the mix. But I don't.

Last year, I used the following scale:

Closeness
Smoothness
Durability
Time
Audible Feedback

with a rating of 1 to 10 for each item. Smoothness is defined as lack of irritation.

The next round begins on Thursday, 1 July.

brianw

06-27-2010, 06:59 PM

Okay Im in week 1 and 2

DunEdinRanger

06-28-2010, 07:51 PM

Okay Im in week 1 and 2

The "Week" starts 1 July, and I intend to push each blade to hopefully at least 8 shaves.

DunEdinRanger

06-29-2010, 08:28 PM

One more day and we begin!

DunEdinRanger

06-30-2010, 07:01 PM

For many reasons, and in no particular order:

1 - To compare different razors and blades under somewhat controlled conditions.

2 - By posting information on they shaves go to help members considering which new razors they want to try. Yes, plural.

3 - It's fun and interesting to compare how different razors shave.

4 - To help determine how many good shaves I can get out of one blade.

5 - To see what difference, if any, a year makes.

Tomorrow morning, a chrome open comb micromatic with a ted pella blade starts things off.

olblueyez

06-30-2010, 07:43 PM

DE Shaver

06-30-2010, 08:41 PM

Let us know how you'll like us to join in. I'll shave with a Futur with IP tomorrow to set the standard.

DunEdinRanger

07-01-2010, 04:20 PM

Ok, more than 12 hours after the shave there is no 5 O'Clock Shadow. I'm still BBS in many places, but stubble is beginning to appear along the jawline and parts of the neck.

Perhaps I applied too much pressure, but the OCMM bit me a few times, especially the last pass when I went against the grain. Still, a very very close shave leaving the skin very smooth.

Closeness 10
Smoothness 9 - defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10
Time 8 (20:43)
Audible Feedback 10

I used Real Shaving moisturizing cream and Booster's Mosswood After Shave.

Codfish

07-01-2010, 04:49 PM

Count me in! As a newbie of six months, I am a little embarrassed to say I have 7 of the ten combos covered...looking forward to it starting tonight...

Codfish

DunEdinRanger

07-01-2010, 04:55 PM

Let us know how you'll like us to join in. I'll shave with a Futur with IP tomorrow to set the standard.

It would be nice if we could all follow the same format, using the same ratings system. But the important thing, I think is to go give fellow members feedback over a range of time, regarding and comparing shaves with different razors.

Count me in! As a newbie of six months, I am a little embarrassed to say I have 7 of the ten combos covered...looking forward to it starting tonight...

Codfish

You should be ashamed!! By now you should have all the combos covered. :tongue_sm

Codfish

07-02-2010, 06:50 AM

This is my very first shave with my recently-acquired gold Micromatic. After 12 hours, there is still no 5 O'Clock shadow anywhere, just the feel of stubble on my chin and along my jaw line.

This was a big change from my usual Merkur Vision. The razor felt light and puny in my hands, and grip and balance were not as intuitive as newer models. After making adjustments, I applied as little pressure as possible, letting the razor do the work. The audible feedback was amazing--like strong amplification. I found I was using frequent short strokes to chase the sound, and it helped me get an extremely close shave, with only a little irritation noticeable when I applied my alcohol-based A/S.

Overall, I was amazed at the quality of the shave from a razor that's been around for 80 years, and has weathered that time so well.

Closeness 9+
Smoothness 8+ (defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave)
Durability 9
Time 8 (a minute longer than usual))
Audible Feedback 10 (this razor really amplified cutting sounds)

I used face-lathering, Proraso cream and Booster's Polar Ice for my after-shave splash.

Final impressions at the end of the week.

Codfish

DunEdinRanger

07-02-2010, 06:16 PM

"Holy Flurping Snit, Kang" as the cyclopean alien overlords would say on The Simpsons, I'm still BBS, after 9 PM.

Closeness 10
Smoothness 8.0 - defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10
Time 8 (21:32) 3 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 10
SC Taylor of Old Bond Street, St. James
AS Clubman, by Pinaud

This is an incredible shave. Today I used TOBS St. James and generated a nice thick rich lather. No nicks, no cuts, and an effortless shave. Three passes with some skin stretching and now the whiskers are afraid - very afraid. I did feel the famed Clubman Sting, but that is really par for the course.

DunEdinRanger

07-02-2010, 06:18 PM

Closeness 9+
Smoothness 8+ (defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave)
Durability 9
Time 8 (a minute longer than usual))
Audible Feedback 10 (this razor really amplified cutting sounds)

I used face-lathering, Proraso cream and Booster's Polar Ice for my after-shave splash.

Final impressions at the end of the week.

Codfish

How did you manage to shave in 8 minutes?!

I'm glad you liked the MM, thanks for joining in, and keep those reports coming!

DunEdinRanger

07-03-2010, 07:08 PM

Closeness 10
Smoothness 9.5 - defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10
Time 6.5 (23:32) 3 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 10
SS My Time Bath & Body Oak Moss
AS Jickey by Booster

Reaaly, an incredible shave. I am still smooth over 12 hours later. The OCMM is setting the bar high for the other razors in this competition.

DunEdinRanger

07-04-2010, 08:19 PM

More than 12 hours after shaving, there is only a slight area of stubble along one jawline. Another BBS shave. The OCMM is really one of the best razors out there.

Closeness 10
Smoothness 9.5 - defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10
Time 9.0 (19:24) 3 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 10
SS Mama Bear's Awakenings
AS Osage Rub

DunEdinRanger

07-05-2010, 11:52 AM

Today, I am taking a day off from shaving.

Codfish

07-06-2010, 07:48 AM

I just returned from a mini-vacation in the Adirondacks, where I didn't have access to a computer to log my shaves.

My Micromatic continues to give excellent results, though I am noticing that the first pass is dragging noticeably more each day, to the point where I am not sure it will actually accomplish its job. But it does!

Now that I'm getting used to it, my shaves have actually gotten better. It is so much more maneuverable than my long handles, that my technique has improved, and my problem areas are now getting closer and smoother shaves than with my Vision and Sledgehammer!

I continue to be amazed at the quality of the shave from a razor that's been around for 80 years.

Closeness 10
Smoothness 9+ (defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave)
Durability 10
Time 8 (I don't use a watch--a little longer than usual for 3 passes and a touch-up)
Audible Feedback 10 (this razor can almost be used with my eyes closed since the sound alone is so accurate)

I used face-lathering, Proraso cream and Ogallala Bay Rum for my after-shave splash during my stay. I'm now back home and ready to put a wrap on week 1.

Codfish

Codfish

07-06-2010, 09:33 AM

I would have to classify this morning's shave as the best I've ever had. Not 100% BBS, but darn close to it! even my problem area over the end of my lips got the closest I've ever experienced.

The razor (I've only used one blade for six shaves) is showing signs of dulling. First pass was rough, and I found I needed a lot more short strokes to get the job done, but it worked fine. A little more burning noticeable when I applied Booster's.

Closeness 10
Smoothness 9 (defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave)
Durability 9 (after 12 hours)
Time 8 (I don't use a watch--a little longer than usual for 3 passes and touch-ups)
Audible Feedback 10 (sound is the best feedback regarding shave closeness)

I used face-lathering, Cremo cream (my Proraso ran out) and Booster's Polar Ice for my after-shave splash. Cremo made a nice, slick but thin lather with the aid of my brush and a little hot water.

Codfish

DunEdinRanger

07-06-2010, 06:25 PM

I had a two day growth this morning when I stepped out of the shower.

To make things more complicated, I had hit snooze a few times, and didn't wake up right away.

The end result: Still Smooth, and mostly BBS even after more than 12 hours. How smooth? :thumbup: That smooth.

Closeness 10
Smoothness 9.5 - defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10
Time 9.0 (20:31) 3 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 10
SS My Time Bath & Body "Old School"
AS Osage Rub

DunEdinRanger

07-06-2010, 06:27 PM

Codfish

07-07-2010, 12:51 PM

My very first completely BBS shave! After seven months, I finally got what I've been looking for.

For my last shave with my Micromatic for a while, I put in a new blade and tried to capitalize on a week's worth of learning...with a perfect shave as the result! I did three passes, with a quick touch-up, and even my problem areas got a smooth shave.

I've been waiting for this day for a while, and am a llittle surprised that my best shave to date came by an 80-year old SE razor. What a great tool when used correctly.

During the entire week, I did not get any cuts, nicks or weepers. I did, however, feel some stinging when I applied Booster's today.

Closeness 10
Smoothness 10 (defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave)
Durability 8 (after 12 hours)
Time 8 (I don't use a watch--a little longer than usual for 3 passes and quick touch-up)
Audible Feedback 10 (sound is the best feedback regarding shave closeness)

I used face-lathering, Cremo cream (my Proraso ran out) and Booster's Polar Ice for my after-shave splash.

Codfish

DunEdinRanger

07-07-2010, 05:56 PM

More than 12 hours later, except for a slight area around the right jawline, I am still BBS. Amazing.

Closeness 10
Smoothness 9.5 - defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10
Time 6.5 (24:416) 3 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 10
SC The Real Shave Company Moisturiizing
AS Osage Rub

and Congratulations to CodFish on BBS!!!

DunEdinRanger

07-08-2010, 06:09 PM

Today I noticed a degradation in the blade. There was some tugging, some pulling, and it took longer to get as close a shave as I want. A smart man would bin the blade, but not me - I'm going to get at least one more shave out of it.

That's because more than 12 hours later, I am still BBS. :thumbup:

Closeness 10
Smoothness 9.5 - defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10
Time 6.5 (25:32) 3 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 10
SS Mama Bear's Awakenings
AS Osage Rub

DunEdinRanger

07-09-2010, 08:09 PM

This was the final shave with the MicroMatic. I'm actually disappointed I only got 8 shaves from one SE Blade.

Closeness 9.5
Smoothness 9.0- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10
Time 6.5 (25:40) 3 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 10
SS Mama Bear's Awakenings
AS Barbasol Pacific Rush

The shave took longer, and the results were not as good as the previous day. The blade still cut, and still pretty smooth, but we move onward in the shave off.

brianw

07-09-2010, 08:14 PM

Only 8 on the blade? I'm disappointed with you Lou !!!!

DunEdinRanger

07-09-2010, 08:27 PM

I am going to make a change in the lineup, from:

1. GEM Open Comb Micromatic (Ted Pella PTFE)
2. 1912 type GEM (Ted Pella PTFE)
3. Merkur Barber Pole Open Comb (12C) (Red Personna)
4. Edwin Jagger DE89L (Feather)
5. Gillette Tuckaway (Derby)
6. Gillette Red Tip TTO (Astra)
7. Gillette SLIM Adjustable (Astra)
8. Merkur Futur (Dorco ST 301)
9. Merkur Barber Pole Slant Bar razor. (Red Personna)
10. Schick Injector

.

To:

1. GEM Open Comb Micromatic (Ted Pella PTFE)
2. 1912 type GEM (Ted Pella PTFE)
2A. Bakelite Open Comb Slant (Red Personna)
3. Merkur Barber Pole Open Comb (12C) (Red Personna)
4. Edwin Jagger DE89L (Feather)
5. Gillette Tuckaway (Derby)
6. Gillette Red Tip TTO (Astra)
7. Gillette SLIM Adjustable (Astra)
8. Merkur Futur (Dorco ST 301)
9. Merkur Barber Pole Slant Bar razor. (Red Personna)
10. Schick Injector

Codfish

07-10-2010, 07:57 AM

My very first shave with my Gem 1912. It did a very good job, but was not as intuitive to use as the Micromatic. I had difficulty finding and maintaining the proper blade angle, and relied on the sound of whiskers being cut as my main guide. I found it challenging to maintain the angle.

I did get a small nick under my nose for a momentary lack of attention, and the shave required a full fourth pass, but the results were very near BBS--with some light stubble on my neck. There was almost no irritation when I applied Booster's.

Overall, a DFS. I think there is a learning curve for me with this razor.

Closeness 9
Smoothness 9 (defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave)
Durability 8 (missed stubble on neck)
Time 7 (I don't use a watch--longer than usual for 4 full passes)
Audible Feedback 9 (sound is the best feedback regarding blade angle)

I used face-lathering, Cremo cream and Booster's Polar Ice for my after-shave splash.

Codfish

brianw

07-10-2010, 11:42 AM

Okay:

1912 Travel today.... Group buy Gem blade, Gent's Best "chilled" soap, LE 2009 Kent brush, Dickenson's witchhazel, Gent's best "chilled" AS.

Closeness 10
Smoothness 9.5- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10 - 8 hours and still BBS (early riser)
Time 10 (10.30 min) 3 Pass + Touchup ( I have a beard so less surface area to worry about)
Audible Feedback 10

Overall a fantastic shave..."chilled" AS a great freezer and end to the perfect shave.

On the road tomorrow to DC and tomorrow nights meetup :thumbup1: Can't decide if 1912 tomorrow or straight... will let you know

DunEdinRanger

07-11-2010, 07:42 AM

I tallied up the results for the OCMM, and out of 50, it has an average score of 46.625. It would be higher if some of the shaves didn't take so long.

Today I shaved with an British made Ever-Ready 1912 model.. A very close, smooth, comfortable shave, and a full report will follow later.

If anyone is curious as to the order... this provides a fairly direct comparison of the OCMM with the 1912 type.

Almost all the Open Combs are grouped together, with the exception of the Tuckaway, which follows the DE 89L. That sequence is to compare two types, and old versus modern.

DunEdinRanger

07-11-2010, 06:42 PM

This was the first shave since Friday morning. There was a good two day growth there. While the shave was very smooth, and BBS, I think I would have to give the edge to the OCMM. But the wee is early.

Closeness 9.5
Smoothness 9.5- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10
Time 6.5 (23:17) 3 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 10
SC AOS Sandalwood
ASBooster's Jickey

Codfish

07-12-2010, 08:43 AM

My second shave with the 1912 left me frustrated again with the difficulty of maintaining blade angle. Again, auditory feedback seems to be the best guide. The razor seems either to do its job, or not, with the slightest variation.

I was able to use my new supply of Proraso, and the shave was close and comfortable, but so UN-intuitive I took yesterday off and switched to my 39C.

No nicks or cuts with the Gem, and almost no irritation when I applied Booster's.

I'll try again today and see if things improve.

Closeness 9.5
Smoothness 9 (defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave)
Durability 9
Time 8 (I don't use a watch--longer than normal))
Audible Feedback 9 (sound is the best feedback regarding blade angle)

I used face-lathering, Proraso soap and Booster's Polar Ice for my after-shave splash.

Codfish

brianw

07-12-2010, 08:59 AM

straight for the last 2 days, 1912 tomorrow

Codfish

07-12-2010, 10:58 AM

This was like a third date with a good-looking girl with annoying habits. No long-term relationship looks likely.

I got a decent shave as the result of scratching at areas that SOUNDED rough. Holding the head almost flat against my face approximated the appropriate angle, but sound again was the best guide.

I'm developing a bad attitude toward it, and may not go back to it again. The resulting shave was good-enough and irritation-free, but on the whole not worth the time and effort--four passes and a lot of touch-ups.

Closeness 9
Smoothness 9 (defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave)
Durability 8 (after 12 hoursl)
Time 7 (considerably longer than normal))
Audible Feedback 9 (sound is the best feedback regarding blade angle)

I used Proraso soap and Booster's Polar Ice for my after-shave splash.

Codfish

brianw

07-12-2010, 11:03 AM

Your experiance is a great example of YMMV. For me a 1912 is the go to razor of the Gems, with a MM down the list past a 1924 and a featherweight

DunEdinRanger

07-12-2010, 06:51 PM

I must hit a time warp between the 2nd and 3rd passes because that's what takes the longest time.

This was the second shave and it was better than the first. The 1912 demands a different type of attention and the angle is just off the face - you can tell by the sound when you have hit the sweet spot.

There was some definite sting from the Clubman, but not as severe as I was expecting. Even now, well more than 12 hours after the shave, I would stay I am at least DFS.

Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 9.5- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10
Time 6.5 (25:30) 3 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 10
SS Oak Moss, My Time Bath & Body
AS Clubman, by Pinaud

DunEdinRanger

07-12-2010, 06:55 PM

This was like a third date with a good-looking girl with annoying habits. No long-term relationship looks likely.

I got a decent shave as the result of scratching at areas that SOUNDED rough. Holding the head almost flat against my face approximated the appropriate angle, but sound again was the best guide.

I'm developing a bad attitude toward it, and may not go back to it again. The resulting shave was good-enough and irritation-free, but on the whole not worth the time and effort--four passes and a lot of touch-ups.

Closeness 9
Smoothness 9 (defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave)
Durability(too early to tell)
Time 7 (considerably longer than normal))
Audible Feedback 9 (sound is the best feedback regarding blade angle)

I used Proraso soap and Booster's Polar Ice for my after-shave splash.

Codfish

I'm not sure if I am describing the same thing, but I have noticed that wher I can not see any stubble, the blade will continue to cut it. It will seek and destroy whiskers with a vengeance,

But the proper blade angle is the key. I have found that by just lifting the head slightly, instead of it being flat I get the best results.

Codfish

07-13-2010, 01:33 PM

I decided to do a fourth shave and forget about technique--just drag the razor around for my normal three passes using no pressure.

I let the audio feedback tell me where to concentrate. My strokes were short compared to my modern razor, and I did a lot of constant touching up as I went, but the shave went quickly and without irritation.

The shave was pretty good all over. I've had better. This will never be a favorite tool of mine, but it's been an interesting experiment. Tomorrow, I'll replace the handle with a longer one to see if it helps with blade angle.

Closeness 9
Smoothness 9.5 (defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave)
Durability (too soon to tell)
Time 8 (only slightly longer than normal))
Audible Feedback 9 (sound is the best feedback regarding blade angle)

I used Proraso soap and Booster's Polar Ice for my after-shave splash.

Codfish

DunEdinRanger

07-13-2010, 05:48 PM

I woke up late, and was rushed to shave this morning. Again over twelve hours since last the blade snagged whiskers, I am not just presentable, but still nearly BBS.

I expected to feel the full force of the PLV sting, but it was a light burning sensation, not the usual fire and brimstone effect.

Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 9.5- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10
Time 8.0 (22:10) 3 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 10
SC Speick (tube)
AS Lilac Vegtal, by Pinaud

DunEdinRanger

07-14-2010, 07:56 PM

Can we say Deja Vu All Over Again?

I woke up late, and was rushed to shave this morning. Again over twelve hours since last the blade snagged whiskers, I am not just presentable, but still nearly BBS.

Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 9.5- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10
Time 9.0 (19:31) 3 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 10
SC Gentlemen's Best
AS Gentlemen's Best

DunEdinRanger

07-15-2010, 07:18 PM

I shaved out of the shower this morning, and while I got a very close, and comfortable shave, there is no way it should have taken 30 minutes.

So tomorrow, I am thinking about popping the blade into the Damaskeene to determine if the time factor will be any different.

Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 9.0- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10
Time 6.0 (31:10) 3 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 10
SC Real Shave Moisturizing
AS Clubman by Pinaud

DunEdinRanger

07-16-2010, 05:19 PM

I shaved out of the shower this morning, with the Damaskeene.

Last night, I decide to switch the blade. I was shocked at what I saw. There was a tremendous amount of gunk under the blade. I knew the blade was done, but being the sort that is dedicated to collecting valuable scientific data (read that as frugal and obstinate, if you must), I forged ahead.

Closeness 9.0
Smoothness 9.5- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 9.5
Time 6.0 (27:51) 3 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 10
SC TOBS Eton College
AS Jickey by Boosters

Tomorrow, I am going to use the Open Comb Slant. :w00t:

DunEdinRanger

07-17-2010, 06:39 PM

First impressions about this razor is that is deadly. There is a tremendous amount of blade exposure!

The second thing is how incredibly light this razor is. It feels like you're holding a feather.

So how does it shave? Whiskers cower before it. It was one of the smoothest shaves I've had. I took it very easy and was very careful. There was no blood for the first (WTG) or second (XTG) pass. But on the third and final pass, on the left side of the neck there appeared a few weepers that to an innocent bystander would have been indicative of an attack by a swarm of baby vampires. They did seal and heal quickly, though.

The audible feedback there is there, but not as loud as with the SE's, Futur, or even the HD/Barber Pole Slants.

Below are the ratings for the first shave, a link to a thread about this razor, and a photo.

Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 9.5- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10
Time 8.0 (23:25) 3 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 8.5
SC AOS Sandalwood
AS Pacific Rush, Barbasol

http://badgerandblade.com/vb/showthread.php?t=158259

http://badgerandblade.com/vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=113710&stc=1&d=1279335298

DunEdinRanger

07-18-2010, 04:20 PM

The downside is it took longer than it should have. The upside is that it was an incredibly, close, smooth shave. More than 12 hours later, it feels like I just shaved.

Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 9.5- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10
Time 6.0 (over 30 minutes5) 3 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 8.5
SC TOBS St. James
AS Mosswood by Booster

DunEdinRanger

07-19-2010, 07:26 PM

I managed to get the time down to under 20 minutes with no discernible loss of quality and more important no loss of blood.

Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 9.5- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10
Time 9.0 (just over 19 minutes) 3 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 8.5
SC Real Shave Co. Moisturizing
AS Osage Rub

DunEdinRanger

07-20-2010, 05:19 PM

I may be getting the hang of this razor. 2 passes +1 touch up pass today.

More than 12 hours since the end of the shave and still clean and smooth.

An outstanding shave, by any measure.

There were only a few scattered weepers which sealed quickly. I still believe I can feel the blade flex as it cuts the hairs, especially on the against the grain cuts.

Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 9.5- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10
Time 6.5 (just over 25 minutes) 3 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 8.5
SC TOBS Eton College
AS Barbasol Pacific Rush
__________________

Jaymo

07-20-2010, 06:13 PM

DunEdinRanger

07-20-2010, 07:07 PM

I'm seriously considering hitting the "Buy It Now" button on one of these Bakelite open comb slants. I wonder how it shaves compared to a Neillite 400, an E type Injector, and a bullet tip Micromatic?

The shave today was as close and as smooth, if not closer and smoother than the Open Comb Micromatic. I haven't shaved with the other razors, so I can't comment on them.

DunEdinRanger

07-21-2010, 07:03 PM

I continue to be impressed by the shave quality. Even now, I have a closer shave than most people get in the morning. There were a few weepers on the neck but not much else. I hope to stretch the blade until Saturday.

Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 9.5- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10
Time 6.5 (just over 23 minutes) 2 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 8.5
SS MB CC Cilantro Lime
AS Barbasol Pacific Rush

Klarion

07-21-2010, 09:47 PM

You are totally making me want to buy some cheap drugstore SE blades to try my OC Micromatic before my Ted Pella group buy comes in.

DunEdinRanger

07-22-2010, 03:33 PM

You are totally making me want to buy some cheap drugstore SE blades to try my OC Micromatic before my Ted Pella group buy comes in.

Snag the GEM branded ones that say Stainless Steel, at the very least.

brianw

07-22-2010, 03:44 PM

Klarion :

Your blades have shipped, you should have them by Sat.....Monday at the latest

Klarion

07-22-2010, 06:34 PM

Klarion :

Your blades have shipped, you should have them by Sat.....Monday at the latest

Wooo! No way will I cave in now.

Hopefully.

DunEdinRanger

07-22-2010, 07:55 PM

Yesterday, I received such a close shave I thought I might be able to skip a day. This morning I thought it might even be a one pass shave.

It was actually a three pass shave, including touchup, and I am pretty sure the whiskers were regenerating as I was shaving. Again the effect, even at this late hour is still mostly smooth.

Merkur - If you're listening, please give us a modern version of the open comb slant! :thumbup1:

Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 9.5- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10
Time 6.5 (just over 23 minutes) 3 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 8.5
SC AOS Sandalwaood
AS Jickey By Boosters

DunEdinRanger

07-23-2010, 06:26 PM

One more shave with the blade, and then we move on to the next razor. Again, using short, quick strokes and no pressure resulted in a great shave. It was BBS when I was done, and I'm feeling very light stubble now, certainly nothing even close to 5 O'Clock Shadow.

Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 9.5- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10
Time 6.5 (just over 22 minutes) 3 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 8.5
SC AOS Sandalwaood
AS Jickey By Boosters

DunEdinRanger

07-24-2010, 07:52 PM

This was the last shave with the Open Comb Slant. More than 12 hours and I am still smooth, nearly BBS everywhere.

I could tell the blade was nearing the end of its useful life. There was some tugging and a few weepers going against the grain.

This is an outstanding razor that provides very close, smooth long lasting shaves.

Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 9.5- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10
Time 6.5 (just over 25 minutes) 3 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 8.5
SS MB Awakening's
AS Osage Rub

DunEdinRanger

07-26-2010, 07:55 PM

I was sporting what is now a two day growth, but honestly the Slant left me with a passable shave even without shaving on Sunday, which was the Feast of St. James.

So today, I used the Open Comb Barber Pole with a fresh Red Pack Personna, and of course it had to be TOBS St. James shave cream. It took a little longer than I expected but I got a great shave. BBS, smooth, and long lasting. Even now there is no trace of 5 O'Clock Shadow.

Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 9.5- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10
Time 6.5 (just over 26 minutes) 3 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 8.5
SC TOBS St. James
AS Clubman

bladeruner

07-27-2010, 07:44 AM

I've just become a fan of this thread. I just wish I had some of these razors to follow along. I use a Merkur 37c exclusively. After reading about the Bakelite open comb I think I'll look for one

DunEdinRanger

07-27-2010, 06:55 PM

This was a very nice, very close, very smooth shave. Even now, there are only a few places where I can feel stubble and this is a major accomplishment for my think beard.

I applied the Booster's and there was a brief sting, not nothing major.

Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 10.0- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10
Time 6.5 (just over 25 minutes) 3 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 8.0
SC AOS Sandalwood
AS Booster's Jickey

DunEdinRanger

07-28-2010, 05:33 PM

What happens when you realize the alarm didn't go off? You hurry, that's what.

This was a shave with poor prep, and I'm being generous in describing it that way. And it was rushed.

The net result is this: A very good shave, BBS mostly, but I did miss a few small spots. Amazing irritation free, as there was no sting from Booster's.

Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 10.0- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 9.0
Time 8.0 (just over 20 minutes) 3 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 8.0
SC The Real Shave
AS Booster's Jickey

DunEdinRanger

07-28-2010, 05:38 PM

I've just become a fan of this thread. I just wish I had some of these razors to follow along. I use a Merkur 37c exclusively. After reading about the Bakelite open comb I think I'll look for one

Welcome. Glad you're following this. The 37C is one of the razors I do not have. Maybe you can shave with it and post your comments when I shave with the EJ DE89L?

Codfish

07-29-2010, 01:07 PM

I got a late start with the 12C because I couldn't give up my Vision 2000 for a few days.

The 12C, with a new Red Pack Persona, gave me an OK shave. Once again I had some difficulty maintaining the proper blade angle, which seemed to vary from too little to too much. Next time, I'll stop trying so hard--that usually works out better for me.

The shave was irritation free, but not the closest I've had. There was little audio feedback to help guide my strokes.

Closeness 8
Smoothness 9 (defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave)
Durability 7
Time 8 (I don't use a watch--a little longer than usual for 3 passes)
Audible Feedback 3 (almost non-existent)

I used Omega shave soap, and Booster's Polar Ice for my after-shave splash.

Codfish

DunEdinRanger

07-29-2010, 04:18 PM

Booster's usually has a very light sting, but today there was no alcohol burn. The shave today was very smooth, and very close. It was a tad long, but thoroughly enjoyable experience.

If more than 12 hours have elapsed since the shave and there is no semblance of 5 O'Clock Shadow and for all intents and purposes one is still smooth, then it was a very good shave,

Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 10.0- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 9.0
Time 6.2 (just over 29 minutes) 3 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 8.0
SC JM Fraser's Mosswood
AS Booster's Mosswodd

bladeruner

07-30-2010, 03:24 PM

Welcome. Glad you're following this. The 37C is one of the razors I do not have. Maybe you can shave with it and post your comments when I shave with the EJ DE89L?

Sounds like a plan :thumbup1:

DunEdinRanger

07-31-2010, 06:42 PM

Yesterday I finished shaving around 6:00 AM, quite early, and essentially on auto pilot. I'm not sure why, but it took less time than normal, 21 minutes, and I had a BBS shave all day.

I didn't shave again until this afternoon, and Shave Number 5 only took 14 minutes! :thumbup1: More on that tomorrow.

Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 10.0- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 8.6 (just over 21 minutes) 3 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 8.0
SC AOS Sandalwood
AS Clubman

DunEdinRanger

08-01-2010, 06:18 AM

I shaved yesterday afternoon, out of the shower, and got another very good, close, comfortable and irritation free shave.

Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 10.0- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 9.0 (just over 14 minutes) 3 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 8.0
SC The Real Shave. Co. Moisturizing.
AS Gentlemen's Best.

DunEdinRanger

08-02-2010, 04:26 PM

Well I corrected one of the post titles. This is what happens when you cut and paste. :001_smile

I have not shaved since Saturday afternoon. I've also decided to try and push the blade to 10 shaves, or Friday morning. I figure that will be a real test.

DunEdinRanger

08-03-2010, 05:49 PM

I went over 60 hours since last shaving. I showered, and then began the task of removing the stubble.

It took just over 30 minutes, but the result was BBS, even now for most of my face, and no irritation. I expected to be brought down by the Clubman Sting but it was just not there.

Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 10.0- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 6.2 (just over 30 minutes) 3 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 8.0
SC TOBS St. James
AS Clubman by Pinaud

DunEdinRanger

08-04-2010, 08:08 PM

Another great shave, but not as great as yesterdays. The blade is showing signs of wear.

Closeness 9.8
Smoothness 9.8- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 9.8
Time 8.0 (just over 24 minutes) 3 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 8.0
SS Almond Cherry
AS Jickey by Boosters

DunEdinRanger

08-05-2010, 04:21 PM

I really thought, when I started this shave, that I should have binned the blade. It didn't feel like it was cutting. By the time I was done, it was BBS, if slightly more irritation than I have been accustomed to from the 12C.

The net result is that once again, more than 12 hours after shaving I ma still clean cut, smooth, and nearly BBS. :thumbup1:

Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 9.0- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 6.0 (just over 29 minutes) 3 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 8.0
SC Gentlemen's Best
AS Gentlemen's Best

brianw

08-05-2010, 04:54 PM

Isn't it hard to shave from that fence???

DunEdinRanger

08-05-2010, 04:56 PM

Isn't it hard to shave from that fence???

It adds to the challenge. :tongue_sm

brianw

08-05-2010, 07:00 PM

Jump down, turn around , pick a bale.....oops forgot no singing here

DunEdinRanger

08-06-2010, 06:12 PM

This was the 10th and last shave with the 12C for the Shave Off. There were a few nicks and the blade wasn't cutting as effectively. I definitely pushed the blade, but really wanted to find out how far it could go.

Tomorrow, it is a new blade and a new razor.

Closeness 9.8
Smoothness 9.4- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 9.6
Time 6.8 (just over 29 minutes) 3 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 8.0
SC TOBS St. James
AS Jickey by Boosters

brianw

08-06-2010, 06:16 PM

What razor tomorrow? , "Silver City" Lou

bladeruner

08-06-2010, 06:36 PM

Hey Lou I'll be joining you tomorrow with my 37c. I just don't know what blade to choose. I use nothing but Gillette super thin's in mine so I feel like I should choose something different but work so well in it.

Suggestions anyone?

DunEdinRanger

08-06-2010, 08:08 PM

Tomorrow is the Edwin Jagger "Differential Equation" DE 89L with a Feather Hi Stainless blade.

BR, keep what works for you. :thumbup:

brianw

08-06-2010, 08:12 PM

I'll put the straights away for a week... and jump in with a injector...don't want to get caught on the fence you know

DunEdinRanger

08-07-2010, 06:14 AM

The Injector is on the schedule!

brianw

08-07-2010, 06:17 AM

How soon on that lou ??

DunEdinRanger

08-07-2010, 03:33 PM

How soon on that lou ??

Here's the schedule:

1. GEM Open Comb Micromatic (Ted Pella PTFE)
2. 1912 type GEM (Ted Pella PTFE)
2A. Bakelite Open Comb Slant (Red Personna)
3. Merkur Barber Pole Open Comb (12C) (Red Personna)
4. Edwin Jagger DE89L (Feather)
5. Gillette Tuckaway (Derby)
6. Gillette Red Tip TTO (Astra)
7. Gillette SLIM Adjustable (Astra)
8. Merkur Futur (Dorco ST 301)
9. Merkur Barber Pole Slant Bar razor. (Red Personna)
10. Schick Injector

DunEdinRanger

08-10-2010, 06:42 PM

I waited until Saturday afternoon to shave.

I used a Feather Hi Stainless with the razor and it took off a lot of stubble, and a wee bit of blood. Sunday morning, more than 12 hours afterward, still felt smooth.

Closeness 9.5
Smoothness 9.4- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 8.0 (just over 23 minutes) 3 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 5.0
SC TOBS Eton College
AS Jickey by Boosters

DunEdinRanger

08-10-2010, 06:43 PM

A very close shave with no weepers or nicks. The lack of intense audible feedback is very discernible.

Closeness 9.8
Smoothness 9.4- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 9.6
Time 10.0 (just over 15 minutes) 3 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 5.0
SC TOBS St. James
AS Jickey by Boosters

DunEdinRanger

08-10-2010, 06:46 PM

This was a rushed shave, just over 20 minutes, because I was running late.

Not a great shave, but not a bad one either.

Closeness 9.8
Smoothness 9.4- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 9.6
Time 8.5.0 (just over 20 minutes) 3 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 5.0
SC TOBS The Real Shaving Co. Moisturizing
AS Gentlemen's Best CHILLED

DunEdinRanger

08-10-2010, 06:47 PM

Not sure what I did differently, but this was closer, and longer lasting than the other shaves with this combination.

Closeness 10
Smoothness 9.4- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10
Time 10.0 (just over 15 minutes) 3 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 5.0
SC TOBS St. James
AS Jickey by Boosters

brianw

08-10-2010, 08:17 PM

Lou I think you need to change to a chain link fence

DunEdinRanger

08-11-2010, 07:03 AM

Lou I think you need to change to a chain link fence

I should know better, but why?

Incidentally, I think the line under your avatar should read, "Hey, let's get a group buy together!" :thumbup1:

DunEdinRanger

08-11-2010, 05:39 PM

I certainly took my time this morning, and am thinking this is the key with this razor. Certainly there was very little burn from the AS, and the only trouble spot is right under the chin, otherwise, even now am still mostly BBS.

Tomorrow is Thursday, and it will be Shave Number 6. I am going to try and get to at least Saturday with the razor and blade for 8 shaves. Maybe even 10...

Closeness 10
Smoothness 9.8- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10
Time 6.0 (just over 30 minutes) 3 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 5.0
SS Mama Bear's Awakenings
AS Gentlemen's Best Signature Series CHILLED

Codfish

08-12-2010, 07:05 AM

I have a DE86. Is that the same head as the DE89L, and does it count this week?

Codfish

DunEdinRanger

08-12-2010, 08:36 AM

Yes, it does.

brianw

08-12-2010, 12:51 PM

I should know better, but why?

Incidentally, I think the line under your avatar should read, "Hey, let's get a group buy together!" :thumbup1:

But who would trust a man that looks like "Boris Badenov...the spy you love to hate"

DunEdinRanger

08-12-2010, 05:05 PM

Wow. This was a great shave. Still smooth more than 12 hours after the shave. I was feeling the smoothness on the commute home.

The difference? I went first with the grain along the jawline instead of across.

Closeness 10
Smoothness 9.8- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10
Time 6.0 (just over 30 minutes) 3 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 5.0
SC TOBS Eton College
AS Osage Rub

DunEdinRanger

08-13-2010, 04:06 PM

This was another great shave. One nick, a self healer, and really close and smooth. I could still pass for clean shaven, even now, more than 12 hours after the shave.

Closeness 10
Smoothness 10- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10
Time 6.8 (just over 26 minutes) 3 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 5.0
SS PC Almond Cherry
AS Booster's MOSSWOOD :thumbup1:

DunEdinRanger

08-14-2010, 04:28 PM

I shaved way early this morning and the result was another outstanding shave. I'm still clean shave and nearly BBS more than 12 hours after the shave ended.

Dare I risk a 9th shave?

Closeness 10
Smoothness 10- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10
Time 6.8 (just over 30 minutes) 4 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 5.0
SS TABAC
AS Booster's Ice Lime

Codfish

08-15-2010, 01:44 PM

I've been told that the DE 86 has the same shaving head as the DE 89L and it qualifies for this week.

I was quickly reminded why this is the least-favorite razor in my collection. I assumed the blade was still sharp, since I almost never use it, but the first three passes accomplished very little. So I put a new Red Pack in and repeated the shave with four additional passes.

I remember clearly why less-aggressive razors are largely ignored by me. I'll try again tomorrow and see if I get better results.

The shaves were irritation free, but not the closest I've had. There was some degree of audio feedback to help guide my strokes.

Closeness 8
Smoothness 9 (defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave)
Durability 8 (after 12 hours)
Time 4 (I don't use a watch--a lot longer than usual for 7 passes)
Audible Feedback 7

I used Omega shave soap, and Booster's Polar Ice for my after-shave splash.

Codfish

DunEdinRanger

08-15-2010, 05:03 PM

I risked a 9th shave, before a 5K run this morning. I wanted to look good for the cameras.:thumbup:

More than twelve hours after the shave, and just one rough spot along the jawline.

I'm going to stick with the Tabac tomorrow, and go for shave 10 with the same blade.

An astute reader will notice the audible feedback was higher. I really thought it was much louder this morning.

Closeness 9.8
Smoothness 10- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 9.8
Time 6.8 (just over 30 minutes) 4 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 6.8.0
SS TABAC
AS Jickey

DunEdinRanger

08-16-2010, 05:51 PM

Is it the Tabac? This was my best shave yet with this razor and blade. More than 12 hours since shaving in the morning, and I am virtually BBS still.

I keep rubbing my face amazed at how smooth it still is.

Closeness 10
Smoothness 10- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10
Time 6.8 (just over 32 minutes) 4 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 6.8
SS TABAC
AS Jickey

Codfish

08-17-2010, 06:19 PM

I am learning a lot as the result of participating in this shave-off. I've confirmed some of my earlier biases about razors and blades, but have also learned that some of my opinions were just plain wrong. More about this at the end of this year's experiment.

One theme that is coming through is that I seem to get better shaves with more aggressive razors. Case in point: my Edwin Jagger.

As comfortable as this is to use--the most irritation-free I can remember--it just doesn't seem to shave as close or remain as durable as others. I will try again tomorrow.

The shave was absolutely irritation free, but not the closest I've had, nor did it seem to last more than a few hours.

Closeness 8
Smoothness 10 (defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave)
Durability 6 (after 12 hours)
Time 8 (3 passes, about average time)
Audible Feedback 7

I used Omega shave soap, and Booster's Polar Ice for my after-shave splash.

Codfish

DunEdinRanger

08-17-2010, 06:27 PM

This was the first shave with the Tuckaway, ever. It has a fresh Derby blade of the horizontal packaging.

The first shave was good, and certainly BBS at work, but not as good as the last shaves with the Jagger. This razor is very nimble and maneuverable, but I may have had some difficulty in finding the sweet spot.

Closeness 9.8
Smoothness 9.8- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 9.8
Time 6.8 (just over 30 minutes) 4 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 6.8
SS TABAC
AS Jickey

DunEdinRanger

08-18-2010, 06:32 PM

This was a better shave than yesterday. Except for a few rough spots along the jawline, which showed up after noon, this was a long lasting shave.

I decided to change the soap and AS today only to wind up "Rocking The Veg". There was a definite Pinaud Burn but it was not too bad .

Closeness 9.8
Smoothness 9.0- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 9.9
Time 6.1 (just over 34 minutes) 4 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 6.8
SS PC Lilac
AS Pinaud Clubman Lilac Vegetal

brianw

08-18-2010, 06:51 PM

Did any cats follow you home????

DunEdinRanger

08-18-2010, 07:55 PM

Did any cats follow you home????

I wish, that was the whole purpose of using it today! :lol:

DunEdinRanger

08-19-2010, 04:49 PM

This was a much better shave than yesterday. Still smooth even now, though right after shaving it did feel a little rough.

Closeness 9.9
Smoothness 9.5- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability10.0
Time 6.1 (just over 32 minutes) 3 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 6.8
SS My Time Bath & Body Oak Moss
AS Pinaud Clubman Virgin Island Bay Rum

DunEdinRanger

08-21-2010, 01:16 PM

Another very good shave. I was smooth well after I got home from work. Unfortunately I fell asleep before I could post this. :biggrin1:

There was some sting from the Clubman, but that is to be expected.

Closeness 9.9
Smoothness 9.1- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability10.0
Time 6.0 (just over 34 minutes) 3 Pass + Touchup
Audible Feedback 6.8
SS TOBS St. James
AS Pinaud Virgin Isle Bay Rum

DunEdinRanger

08-21-2010, 06:18 PM

I shaved this morning and while I was a bit rushed for time, still achieved a great shave. There were no nicks or cuts. I was still smooth and clean shaven more than 12 hours later.

I was not completely awake, and inadvertently used Clubman Hair Tonic as after shave. It did sting quite a bit more than the Boosters.

Closeness 9.9
Smoothness 9.9- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability10.0
Time 8.0 (just over 26 minutes) 3 Pass
Audible Feedback 6.8
SC TABAC
AS Booster's Jickey

Tomorrow will be Shave #6 - Not sure if I should stretch it out, or just start the work week with the Red Tip...

DunEdinRanger

08-22-2010, 11:33 AM

And here is why:

JoeH

08-22-2010, 07:31 PM

And here is why:

What the heck happened to that blade?

DunEdinRanger

08-22-2010, 07:57 PM

What the heck happened to that blade?

I think it was the reaction of the two metals, silver and steel. I have an Astra Keramik in the Red Tip for tomorrow.

DunEdinRanger

08-22-2010, 08:01 PM

This was the last shave with the Tuckaway during the shave off. It did not feel like the blade was cutting much, and the usual problem areas with this razor - the jawline and the neck around the ears took considerable effort to shave,

I was surprised by how badly corroded the blade got, almost as if it wasn't stainless steel.

Closeness 9.5
Smoothness 9.8- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability9.5
Time 6.5(just over 30 minutes) 3 Pass + Touch Up
Audible Feedback 6.8
SS Mama Bear's Dublin Tweed
AS Booster's Jickey

DunEdinRanger

08-24-2010, 07:34 PM

Yesterday was the first shave with the Red Tip, and it has a fresh Astra Keramik blade.

There was some blood on the lower lip, and in general I did get a good shave, but it just barely lasted the work day

The audible feedback was unusual, in that in some areas, notably the lower lip and around the chin was much higher than the cheek area.

Closeness 9.5
Smoothness 9.8- defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 9.5
Time 8.0(just over 25 minutes) 3 Pass + Touch Up
Audible Feedback 8.0
SC TOBS St. James
AS Gentlemen's Best CHILLED

DunEdinRanger

08-24-2010, 07:38 PM

Shave Number 2 was an improvement though blood was still drawn in the same spot as Monday.

The shave definitely lasted longer, and felt closer and smoother throughout the day than after the 1st shave with this combination. Even at this late hour, I am still more than presentable.

Closeness 9.9
Smoothness 9.3 - defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 9.9
Time 8.0(just over 23 minutes) 3 Pass + Touch Up
Audible Feedback 8.2
SS TABAC
AS Booster's Jickey

DunEdinRanger

08-25-2010, 06:19 PM

This was also an improvement over the 2nd shave. It took slightly less time, and was close, and more durable.

Again, more than 12 hours later, the shave is still good.

Closeness 9.9
Smoothness 9.3 - defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 8.1 (just over 21 minutes) 3 Pass + Touch Up
Audible Feedback 8.4
SS TABAC
AS Booster's Jickey

DunEdinRanger

08-26-2010, 06:08 PM

This was a very nice shave. Very smooth and close all around. I think the Merkur OC, and the Jagger provided closer, longer lasting shaves among the DE's, and the Micromatic likewise, but 21 minutes start to finish is pretty good.

Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 9.8 - defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 8.1 (just over 21 minutes) 3 Pass + Touch Up
Audible Feedback 8.4
SC JM Fraser's MOSSWOOD
AS Booster's MOSSWOOD

DunEdinRanger

08-27-2010, 06:49 PM

I did take it very slowly this morning, and did not rush anything. The result was a shave that took considerably longer, but also lasted longer.

My standard is the 12 hour shave. If the shave last 12 hours, it gets a 10 rating for closeness. The Micromatic, and the Open Combs with the exception of the Tuckaway all easily exceeded that standard. Today was the first day the Red Tip came close to the standard set by those razors.

Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 9.9 - defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 6.1 (just over 31 minutes) 3 Pass + Touch Up
Audible Feedback 8.4
SC TOBS St. James
AS Booster's Oriental Spice

noahpictures

08-27-2010, 10:07 PM

This is very cool and I'm interested. I have to say I'm surprised how you can make the blades last so long. Is there a secret? What type of beard do you have?

DunEdinRanger

08-28-2010, 06:15 PM

This is very cool and I'm interested. I have to say I'm surprised how you can make the blades last so long. Is there a secret? What type of beard do you have?

Noah,

I'm not sure there is a secret.

I have a thick, dark, fast growing stubble. When shaving with electrics I would get 5 O'Clock Shadow at 9 AM. I consider myself to have sensitive skin since the multiblades would always irritate my neck.

I do tend to use short, quick strokes and rinse the blade out often while shaving, but I doubt that extends the serviceability of the blade.

DunEdinRanger

08-28-2010, 06:20 PM

I shaved early this morning and took my time. The result was an ultra BBS shave which I thoroughly enjoyed. Even now, I am mostly smooth but still clean shaven.

Tomorrow, I try the TABAC which may add further evidence that one gets a better, closer shave from soaps/creams with Tallow.

Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 9.9 - defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 6.1 (just over 34 minutes) 3 Pass + Touch Up
Audible Feedback 8.4
SS My Time Bath & Body "Old School"
AS Stephan Bay Rum

DunEdinRanger

08-29-2010, 05:03 PM

I set out this morning to achieve ultra BBS, and I was successful. I think I hit a time warp between the 2nd and 3rd passes because I'm not sure how it took so long, but the shave is still very smooth, more than 12 hours later.

I did feel the sting from the After Shave.

So now the question is this - Can I complete the week with the same blade?

Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 9.0 -defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 6.1 (just over 34 minutes) 4 Pass + Touch Up
Audible Feedback 8.4
SC TABAC
AS Gentlemen's Best Signature

DunEdinRanger

08-30-2010, 06:30 PM

Very close shave, and very durable. Even now am still clean shaven.

However, this shave felt a bit rough. The Clubman AS burned. But it was a very close shave! :thumbup:

Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 8.5 -defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 6.6 (just over 28 minutes) 4 Pass + Touch Up
Audible Feedback 8.4
SC TOBS Eton College
AS Clubman

Swampfox

08-30-2010, 06:43 PM

DunEdinRanger

08-31-2010, 06:42 PM

Yes, Shave 9 and the blade is still going strong.
I'm still unbelievably smooth, more than 12 hours after the shave.

Wow. Just Wow.

Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 9.0 -defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 6.6 (just under 28 minutes) 4 Pass + Touch Up
Audible Feedback 8.4
SS TABAC
AS Barbasol Pacific Rush

DunEdinRanger

09-01-2010, 07:27 PM

This was another great shave. I thought it was going to be a quick shave, but the touch up took a bit longer than expected. Still, even now I don't show a 5 O'Clock Shadow.

The Osage Rub froze my face and my hands. :thumbup1:

Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 9.5 -defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 6.9 (just under 25 minutes) 4 Pass + Touch Up
Audible Feedback 8.4
SC TOBS Eton College
AS Osage Rub

DunEdinRanger

09-02-2010, 06:53 PM

Yes, you read that correctly. Eleven shaves with the same blade.

It was a smooth shave, notwithstanding the initial sting of the AS which then went to a long slow cool.

Bit the shave was long lasting, with a few small nicks. Tomorrow is Shave 12 with the blade. I may retire it at that point, and then bring in the SLIM, or try to eke one more shave out of it.

Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 9.4 -defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 6.5 (just under 30 minutes) 4 Pass + Touch Up
Audible Feedback 8.4
SS TABAC
AS Gentlemen's Best CHILLED

brianw

09-02-2010, 06:55 PM

You Sir are a glutton for punishment

DunEdinRanger

09-02-2010, 07:12 PM

You Sir are a glutton for punishment

I think the word you're looking for is thrifty. :lol:

brianw

09-02-2010, 07:22 PM

No that's not the one........:tongue_sm

DunEdinRanger

09-02-2010, 07:34 PM

No that's not the one........:tongue_sm

Prudent? Sensible? Frugal? :tongue_sm

brianw

09-02-2010, 07:47 PM

No, No, No....but your getting closer :blushing::blushing:

DunEdinRanger

09-03-2010, 03:01 PM

Thought I would post a photo or two... of what a blade looks like after 12 shaves, after being rinsed thoroughly after every shave.

noahpictures

09-03-2010, 03:33 PM

You shaved your face with that? How was the shave? Thanks for the pics. :thumbup1:

DunEdinRanger

09-03-2010, 04:12 PM

You shaved your face with that? How was the shave? Thanks for the pics. :thumbup1:

Yes, I did. The blade looked far worse in the photos than in actuality. There was no rust, just a lot of soap scum, which may have been a protective film. :001_rolle

But how was the shave? It was not as smooth as the previous shaves; there was certainly a degradation in the blade's ability to effortlessly mow down whiskers.

But it did cut them down. And the goal today was a two day shave. I really don't want to shave tomorrow, and would like at least one day off from shaving.

The net result is I think I may have succeeded. I am very smooth right now, except for one small spot along the jawline.

The Slim is ready, primed with a Croma Diamant blade.

Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 9.4 -defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 6.5 (just under 39 minutes) 4 Pass + Touch Up
Audible Feedback 8.4
SC SPEICK
AS Booster's JICKEY

DunEdinRanger

09-05-2010, 05:53 PM

I decided to use a Croma Diamant blade in the Slim Adjustable set to 9. . I had a two day growth, and in 20 minutes it was gone. This was a very close, smooth shaved. Defintely closer than anything produced by the Red Tip.

Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 9.8 -defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 9.8 (just under 21 minutes) 4 Pass + Touch Up
Audible Feedback 8.4
SS TABAC
AS Clubman, by Pinaud

brianw

09-05-2010, 06:02 PM

what did you have that slim dialed to ??

DunEdinRanger

09-05-2010, 07:15 PM

what did you have that slim dialed to ??

Thanks! I knew I forgot something. I fixed the post, but it is set to 9.

Swampfox

09-06-2010, 09:24 AM

Wingnut

09-06-2010, 11:02 AM

I have always been afraid to crank up my adjustables that high. Maybe I should try it out.

You know, when I started shaving with a Slim, I set the razor to "3" and just forgot about it, to try to keep things on a level playing field. I figured, "I've got a rather light and fine beard, so why risk getting cut up needlessly?" I got fine shaves (DFS+) with minimal irritation, and so just stayed at 3 and didn't give it more thought for 6 months or so.

In the past few weeks, though, I've begun experimenting with more aggressive settings (I've gone all the way up to 8), and to my surprise I'm getting both a closer shave and less overall irritation than with a milder setting. Lately, I've been gravitating to about a "7" as best for me.

My guess is that, now that my technique has settled down and I can safely handle more blade exposure, I am removing more beard with each stroke, so I need less touchups. The result is a paradox: my skin feels less irritated with a setting of 7 than it did at 3.:thumbup1:

Ray, give that adjustable a click or two towards the wild side - you may be surprised at how good your face will feel afterwards.

Swampfox

09-06-2010, 11:10 AM

Ray, give that adjustable a click or two towards the wild side - you may be surprised at how good your face will feel afterwards.

I think I may. I was going to start an injector run this week, but I may hold off on that until Sunday. Test out the adjustables again, and a couple other razors. Try to figure out if I can make a Segal take a regular DE, things like that. I just might try the Slim or Super on 9 tonight.

DunEdinRanger

09-06-2010, 04:47 PM

I think I may. I was going to start an injector run this week, but I may hold off on that until Sunday. Test out the adjustables again, and a couple other razors. Try to figure out if I can make a Segal take a regular DE, things like that. I just might try the Slim or Super on 9 tonight.

Do it Ray!! :001_smile

I didn't shave today, but tomorrow is a work day!

noahpictures

09-06-2010, 10:52 PM

Do it Ray!! :001_smile

I didn't shave today, but tomorrow is a work day!

Slilm at 9, well that's dare devil stuff!

Swampfox

09-07-2010, 03:31 AM

Well, I did it. I took the Super up to 9. Nice shave on the face, the neck had some irritation. Not a bad shave. Not as good as what I get with the SEs, but still the best I've had with the adjustables. I think I might take it down to 7 tonight, though.

Codfish

09-07-2010, 01:25 PM

WOW! What an idea!

I'm a lover of aggressive razors, but never dared turn my adjustables all the way up. After reading Lou's post, I decided to give it a try. The results were fantastic! Close and smooth. I had never thought I could withstand a setting of 9...

The shave was irritation free, it may be the closest I've ever had. Even in my problem upper-lip area.

Closeness 10
Smoothness 10 (defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave)
Durability 9 after 12 hours (no shadow, just a little stubble)
Time 9.5 (3 easy passes)
Audible Feedback 9

I used Proraso shave cream and Booster's Polar Ice for my after-shave splash.

Gonna try my Vision at the highest setting next week.

Codfish

DunEdinRanger

09-07-2010, 06:20 PM

I'm glad to hear people have tried their Slims at 9, and not only lived to tell about it, but also enjoyed the shave! :thumbup:

This was the 2nd shave, and again it was a good 12 hour shave. I'm still smooth along the cheeks, and around the lips, even at this hour.

I used the same AS as on Sunday, but on Sunday there was a slight mishap as I first applied the Clubman hair tonic on my face. :lol: Today, I definitely felt the Clubman Sting.

Adjustable Setting: 9
Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 9.4 -defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 6.9 (just under 28 minutes) 4 Pass + Touch Up
Audible Feedback 8.4
SS Mama Bear's CC Autumn
AS Clubman, by Pinaud

Codfish

09-08-2010, 07:38 AM

I'm amazed! This was hands-down my finest shave in memory.

Absolutely BBS everywhere. No irritation at all--even after a cologne application!

Closeness 10
Smoothness 10 (defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave)
Durability 9.5 (hardly any stubble after 12 hours)
Time 10 (3 easy passes)
Audible Feedback 9.5 (not loud, but enough to be helpful)

I used Proraso shave cream and Booster's Polar Ice for my after-shave splash. Usher VIP cologne.

Without doubt, the finest shave I can remember!

Codfish

DunEdinRanger

09-08-2010, 08:25 PM

I am pretty sure the Croma blade does not like me very much. I believe I would be getting better shaves with the Red Pack Personna's or Astras.

In any event, there were a few nicks this shave. It was a very smooth shave, but not as good as the previous one. There is nothing quantitative I can point to. It certainly lasted all day. I still don't have 5 O'Clock shadow, but when Booster's stings...

Adjustable Setting: 9
Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 9.4 -defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 6.9 (just under 28 minutes) 4 Pass + Touch Up
Audible Feedback 8.4
SC TOBS Eton College
AS Jickey by Boosters

Codfish

09-09-2010, 01:28 PM

What can I say that I haven't already?

Another BBS, irritation-free shave.

Razor Setting 9
Closeness 10
Smoothness 10 (defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave)
Durability 10 (UPDATE: not even a 5 o'clock shadow after 26 hours!)
Time 10 (3 easy passes)
Audible Feedback 9.5 (not loud, but enough to be helpful)

I used Proraso shave cream and Booster's Polar Ice for my after-shave splash.

A fine shave in a week of fine shaves!

Codfish

DunEdinRanger

09-09-2010, 05:45 PM

Right out of the shower, running a bit late, and rushed it a bit. There were no nicks, but there was some stinging with the aftershave. I think I felt the blade tug a little, especially going against the grain.

Gentlemen, don't be afraid to use the Slim on the 9 setting! Codfish, thanks for your comments!

Adjustable Setting: 9
Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 9.4 -defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 8.9 (just under 21 minutes)3 Pass + Touch Up
Audible Feedback 8.4
SS TABAC
AS Gentlemen's Best Signature Series

Swampfox

09-10-2010, 02:59 AM

I tried my Slim again on high last night. This time I went with the 7, Shark blade again, and Godrej Menthol Mist - wow! that stuff is cold!

Again, I got a very good shave, no noticeable irritation, but the alum, witchazel and AS gave me some sting. No where near as good as what I get out of the SEs, but aceptable enough that I may keep my Slim after all.

DunEdinRanger

09-10-2010, 03:32 PM

I woke up early, and with plenty of time showered and shaved. So, taking my time, and being very careful produced an exemplary shave. I am still BBS 12 hours after the fact.

Adjustable Setting: 9
Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 9.5 -defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 8.5 (just under 25 minutes)3 Pass + Touch Up
Audible Feedback 8.4
SC TOBS St. James
AS Booster's Jickey

DunEdinRanger

09-11-2010, 04:02 PM

I decided to switch razors today, and went with the Futur. I had forgotten just how good this razor is. This was a shave that did not take much time, was extremely close and BBS

A full report will be forthcoming tomorrow.

Codfish

09-11-2010, 05:16 PM

DunEdinRanger

09-11-2010, 06:26 PM

For today's shave, I used one of my two favorite, best-shaving razors (Sledgehammer Slant) to compare with the Slim. I was surprised to find that the Slim, set at 9, has consistently performed better than my slant.

Codfish

I've got the pitchforks ready. Who's got the torches? :lol:

The Slim has given me the best shaves of any non gold plated Gillette TTO I have tried, but then that isn't saying much. :tongue_sm

noahpictures

09-12-2010, 12:17 AM

DunEdinRanger

09-12-2010, 03:37 AM

Yeah, I'm up early.

WOW. I think the whiskers were quivering in fear and jumping off rather than face the onslaught of the mighty Futur. Here it is, well more than 12 hours after the shave and I am still BBS.

I don't know if the Barber Pole Slant can top this...

Adjustable Setting: 6.5 (DORCO ST301 Blade)
Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 9.5 -defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0 +
Time 9.5 (just over 16 minutes) 3 Pass + Touch Up
Audible Feedback 10.0
SC WARS
AS Clubman by Pinaud

Swampfox

09-12-2010, 06:13 AM

I abandoned the adjustables again in favor of my new Ever-Ready 1912, which I found to be superior to the GEM 1912.I shaved last night and I am still fairly smooth. Impressive. I used a Treet blade and Arko Mist Shave Cream.

Every-Ready 1912
Closeness 9.0
Smoothness 9.0 -defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0 +
Time 6.5 I didn't really keep track of time, but I know it was longer than 20 minutes. SE shaves always take longer.
Audible Feedback 10.0 I could hear the whiskers be mowed down. It sounded wild. I even stopped a couple of time to feel my face to see what was going on.
SC Arko Mist
AS Saint Charles Rose, quite a compliment to such a great shave.

Codfish

09-12-2010, 08:22 AM

Sadly, I don't own a Futur. Faced with sitting this week out, I decided to try shaving with the closest thing I own--my Vision. In the spirit of Lou's "Slim-at-9" experiment, I decided to try it wide-open, set at "V" (with a new Feather blade).

I did this to play out my fascination with aggressive DEs, and I lived to tell about it.

My usual prep, minus coffee, to ensure a steady hand. At first, I was so cautious I was afraid to let the weight of the razor do its work, and tried applying NEGATIVE pressure--until I relaxed after the first pass.

Shave completed: no blood, barely detectable irritation in two small areas when I applied Booster's, and BBS all over!

Setting: "V" (highest)
Closeness 10
Smoothness 9.5 (defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave)
Durability (too soon to tell)
Time 9.5 (3 easy passes)
Audible Feedback 9

I used Proraso shave cream and Booster's Polar Ice for my after-shave.

Thanks to Lou and Evel for the inspiration!

Codfish

noahpictures

09-13-2010, 01:44 PM

I don't have a Futur and now I want one thanks to you guys. I thought RAD was over but you pull me back in! :lol:

DunEdinRanger

09-13-2010, 03:00 PM

I don't have a Futur and now I want one thanks to you guys. I thought RAD was over but you pull me back in! :lol:

Oh, just wait until you hear about today's shave.

DunEdinRanger

09-13-2010, 03:24 PM

I shaved this morning. I took my time. When I was done, I thought only a professional straight shave could have shaved me closer. Even now, I am 99% BBS.

This was extremely close, comfortable, smooth. The only nicks occurred on the touch up because I was going for a very, very, long lasting shave.

I definitely succeeded.

Adjustable Setting: 6.5 (DORCO ST301 Blade)
Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 9.8 -defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0 +
Time 8.5 (just over 25 minutes) 3 Pass + Touch Up
Audible Feedback 10.0
SC TOBS Eton College
AS Clubman by Pinaud

Codfish

09-13-2010, 07:56 PM

I'm so intrigued, I just purchased a gold-tone Futur on BST!

Codfish
http://badgerandblade.com/vb/macskin/misc/progress.gif

DunEdinRanger

09-14-2010, 02:39 AM

I'm so intrigued, I just purchased a gold-tone Futur on BST!

Codfish http://badgerandblade.com/vb/macskin/misc/progress.gif

Congratulations! That's what I have! The only reason I would sell mine is to get a new one.

DunEdinRanger

09-14-2010, 05:56 PM

This shave was out of the shower. Yesterday, I wanted to get a very long lasting shave. Today, the goal was just 12 hours. Both days the goals were exceeded.

This was a quick, very close, comfortable shave. Even now, I can only feel a little stubble along the jawline.

Adjustable Setting: 6.5 (DORCO ST301 Blade)
Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 9.8 -defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 9.9 (just over 17 minutes) 3 Pass + Touch Up
Audible Feedback 10.0
SS TABAC
AS Boosters by Pinaud

DunEdinRanger

09-15-2010, 04:45 PM

If it were possible this was a better shave than Monday. I am still clean shaven, now, more than 12 hours after the shave.

Shaving with the Futur has been very enjoyable this week. The shaves have been as close as an SE, but quicker, and the audible feedback has been just as good.

The Futur and the Open Comb Micromatic (OCMM) both cut whiskers with a throaty growl, the equivalent of a double barreled carburated V8, while other razors cut whiskers and the audible feedback is, "more refined". I think I wake the neighbors by the sound the whiskers make as they are being cut.

Adjustable Setting: 6.5 (DORCO ST301 Blade)
Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 92 -defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 8.8 (just over 23 minutes) 3 Pass + Touch Up
Audible Feedback 10.0
SS TABAC
AS Pinaud Clubman Virgin Isles Bay Rum

noahpictures

09-15-2010, 10:03 PM

I don't have a Futur and now I want one thanks to you guys. I thought RAD was over but you pull me back in! :lol:

I ordered the Futur today. :blush:
I hope it is better than the Progress, which I sold.

DunEdinRanger

09-16-2010, 03:59 PM

I'm so intrigued, I just purchased a gold-tone Futur on BST!

Codfish
http://badgerandblade.com/vb/macskin/misc/progress.gif

I ordered the Futur today. :blush:
I hope it is better than the Progress, which I sold.

I was going to end the Futur early next week. Since both of you gents have ordered one, I'm more than happy to pop a fresh blade in the Futur and continue on if you gents think the razors will be here by the end of next week?

DunEdinRanger

09-16-2010, 04:05 PM

This was another great shave. There were a few weepers, including one that mysteriously appeared long after the pass, during the lathering phase.

Still smooth and clean shaven, even now.

Adjustable Setting: 6.5 (DORCO ST301 Blade)
Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 95 -defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 8.8 (just over 23 minutes) 3 Pass + Touch Up
Audible Feedback 10.0
SC TOBS St. James
AS Pinaud Clubman

Codfish

09-16-2010, 05:23 PM

I was going to end the Futur early next week. Since both of you gents have ordered one, I'm more than happy to pop a fresh blade in the Futur and continue on if you gents think the razors will be here by the end of next week?

Lou, I've been hoping mine would get here in time. It's on its way. I'd be grateful for an opportunity to post my reaction.

Codfish
http://badgerandblade.com/vb/macskin/misc/progress.gif

noahpictures

09-16-2010, 06:23 PM

Lou, I've been hoping mine would get here in time. It's on its way. I'd be grateful for an opportunity to post my reaction.

Codfish
http://badgerandblade.com/vb/macskin/misc/progress.gif

+1 Same here, mine should arrive by Saturday.

DunEdinRanger

09-16-2010, 07:05 PM

DunEdinRanger

09-17-2010, 04:20 PM

Blood Everywhere! I had to use a styptic. This was pure user error. And it was the kind of thing that the very second you're doing, you realize you shouldn't be. I put too much pressure on the downstroke on the upper lip, and the blade hit with a vengeance. Immediate reaction, besides the usual salty language was to check for red stains. Those didn't immediately appear, but when they did, I hit a gusher!

Aside from that little incident, the shave went well. I was smooth and clean shaven all day, even now.

I should retire a blade that tasted that much blood, but I'm hoping it's been sated.

Adjustable Setting: 6.5 (DORCO ST301 Blade)
Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 9.3 -defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 8.8 (just over 24 minutes) 3 Pass + Touch Up
Audible Feedback 10.0
SC PC Almond Cherry
AS Booster's Oriental Spice

brianw

09-17-2010, 04:26 PM

No Rescue squad ????

DunEdinRanger

09-17-2010, 04:28 PM

No Rescue squad ????

I'm banned from calling them ever since the issue with the fence splinters. :tongue_sm

brianw

09-17-2010, 04:29 PM

I'm banned from calling them ever since the issue with the fence splinters. :tongue_sm

:lol::lol::lol::lol::lol:

noahpictures

09-18-2010, 10:52 AM

Well then, we're back to the Futur. :thumbup:

My Futur has arrived. I don't know what blade it likes, maybe I'll go with a Personna (Red). Don't have any Dorco.

DunEdinRanger

09-18-2010, 05:00 PM

A Personna Red is an excellent choice, as is an Astra Platinum.

DunEdinRanger

09-18-2010, 05:11 PM

I still don't understand why shaves out of the shower have taken longer this week, than shaves where I haven't showered immediately preceding.

In any event, the Futur performed admirably, and I am still quite clean shaven, thank you very much. :001_smile

Adjustable Setting: 6.5 (DORCO ST301 Blade)
Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 10-defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 9.9 (just over 16 minutes) 3 Pass + Touch Up
Audible Feedback 10.0
SC The Real Shave Moisturizing
AS Booster's Oriental Spice

DunEdinRanger

09-19-2010, 04:51 PM

Eight shaves with one blade! I'm still smooth and clean shaven now, more than 12 hours after the shave completed.

Tomorrow, the Futur shaves again, but this time with a Red Pack Personna. Everyone else who has one, is more than welcome to join in the fun.

Adjustable Setting: 6.5 (DORCO ST301 Blade)
Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 9.0-defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 8.8 (just over 24 minutes) 3 Pass + Touch Up
Audible Feedback 10.0
SC AOS Sandalwood
AS Gentlemen's Best Signature Series

dirtdog

09-20-2010, 08:25 AM

If it were possible this was a better shave than Monday. I am still clean shaven, now, more than 12 hours after the shave.

You must have a very light beard then. At 12 hours I got stubble

DunEdinRanger

09-20-2010, 03:23 PM

You must have a very light beard then. At 12 hours I got stubble

Not really. I have thick, dark stubble. When shaving with a cartridge or electric, I would get a shadow within a few hours after shaving.

DunEdinRanger

09-20-2010, 03:27 PM

This was the first shave with the RPP, and it was a very smooth, close, comfortable shave. It was, in retrospect a better shave than the first shave with the Dorco ST 301's. This may be due to better practice, or having less stubble, or both.

Adjustable Setting: 6.5 (Red Pack Personna)
Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 10-defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 9.1 (just over 21 minutes) 3 Pass + Touch Up
Audible Feedback 10.0
SS TABAC
AS Oriental Spice by Booster's

noahpictures

09-20-2010, 05:24 PM

I am glad I purchased this razor, thanks to this thread. I hated the Merkur Progress (sold it) so I had low expectations. For some reason (again this thread) I set the razor at 6 on the first pass and it sounded great. The best feedback of any razor I have used including the Gem OC and the Slants. At the highest setting the Futur is loud.
I was also amazed at how easy it is to shave with the razor set at 6; I didn't have to fight to find the right angle. Next shave I am going to leave it at 6.

Bottom line I had a BBS without single nick after three passes. I rate harshly when it comes to comfort and yet this razor/blade combo received a 10.

Adjustable Setting: 6 WTG, 3 XTG, ATG (Red Pack Personna)
Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 10-defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 6 ( 24 minutes) 3 Pass + Touch Up
Audible Feedback 10.0
SS TABAC
AS Old Spice

Thanks Lou.

DunEdinRanger

09-20-2010, 06:14 PM

Codfish

09-21-2010, 02:55 PM

Holy cow! The PERFECT SHAVE!!! :thumbup::thumbup::thumbup:

Finall, after nine months of DE shaving, I've arrived. I found the Holy Grail in the form of a gold-plated Futur. There is no way I could wish for better. This is it. I finally arrived...

Smooth, comfortable, durable, fast and without ANY irritation as all. No more than if I passed one of Sweetie's silk hankies over my face.

Adjustable Setting: 6.5 (Super Iridium)
Closeness 10
Smoothness 10-defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 10 (3 Pass, no touch-up)
Audible Feedback 10 (as good as a GEM 1912)
SC Proraso
AS Boosters/Tabac

The only problem I have is that the gold Futur does not blend in well with my other siver/chrome razors. Sweetie noticed it and I'm now in the dog house. Let's just say dinner and candy, and flowers and a movie will not be enough this time.

Watch for my upcoming sales on BST. I promised to sell at least as much as the Furur cost! This weekend (and if she's still ranting, maybe sooner...) :blush:

Codfish

DunEdinRanger

09-21-2010, 06:19 PM

With Autumn in the air, I went with the Oriental Spice and it delivered a great shave. There are areas, which are normally tough, like the corners of the lips that are still BBS now, even going against the grain.

Adjustable Setting: 6.5 (Red Pack Personna)
Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 10-defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 8.6 (just over 24 minutes) 3 Pass + Touch Up
Audible Feedback 10.0
SC JM Fraser's Oriental Spice
AS Oriental Spice by Booster's

DunEdinRanger

09-21-2010, 06:21 PM

Holy cow! The PERFECT SHAVE!!! :thumbup::thumbup::thumbup:

Finall, after nine months of DE shaving, I've arrived. I found the Holy Grail in the form of a gold-plated Future. There is no way I could wish for better. This is it. I finally arrived...

Smooth, comfortable, durable, fast and without ANY irritation as all. No more than if I passed one of Sweetie's silk hankies over my face.

...

The only problem I have is that the gold Futur does not blend in well with my other siver/chrome razors. Sweetie noticed it and I'm now in the dog house. Let's just say dinner and candy, and flowers and a movie will not be enough this time.

Watch for my upcoming sales on BST. I promised to sell at least as much as the Furur cost! This weekend (and if she's still ranting, maybe sooner...)

Codfish

The price of the perfect shave!! Did you try to co-opt SWMBO by offering to shave her legs with one of your razors, and luxurious creams?

OTOH, you're not selling a progress are you? :lol:

Codfish

09-21-2010, 07:15 PM

The price of the perfect shave!! Did you try to co-opt SWMBO by offering to shave her legs with one of your razors, and luxurious creams?

OTOH, you're not selling a progress are you? :lol:

Hadn't thought of that...great idea! :thumbup1:

She'd like the Prairie Creations Rose. Warm lather...silvertip brush...rose balm...yep...worth a try!. :wink2:

Sadly, no Progress. Will have to see what I can part with and will preview here.

Codfish

DunEdinRanger

09-21-2010, 07:17 PM

Hadn't thought of that...great idea! :thumbup1:

She'd like the Prairie Creations Rose. Warm lather...silvertip brush...rose balm...yep...worth a try!. :wink2:

Sadly, no Progress. Will have to see what I can part with and will preview here.

Codfish

Hopefully, you will not have to part with any!

noahpictures

09-21-2010, 07:22 PM

I didn't have much stubble and I also tried cold water shaving with my new Futur and it works. No nicks, irritation and very little razor burn. Cold water shaving is not luxurious but it is very practical. I went extreme with using Proraso Pre and Proraso shaving cream, combined with cold water shaving my face felt frozen. Kind of nice in a cold shower kind of way.

Adjustable Setting: 6 (Red Pack Personna)
Closeness 9.5
Smoothness 10-defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 9
Time 6 (24 minutes) 3 Pass + Touch Up
Audible Feedback 9.5
SC Proraso
AS Provence Sante Green Tea

I shall shave with cold water again tomorrow. :thumbup1:

Codfish

09-21-2010, 08:14 PM

... I went extreme with using Proraso Pre and Proraso shaving cream, combined with cold water shaving my face felt frozen. Kind of nice in a cold shower kind of way.

I've had cold showers, but never by choice and I never understood the charm. But you've got me curious, and I'll try it tomorrow. Sounds a little bit like a Zen thing, but who knows, since all of this is a Zen thing...

Codfish

noahpictures

09-21-2010, 08:58 PM

I've had cold showers, but never by choice and I never understood the charm. But you've got me curious, and I'll try it tomorrow. Sounds a little bit like a Zen thing, but who knows, since all of this is a Zen thing...

Codfish

It certainly felt like a cold shower.

Codfish

09-22-2010, 09:27 AM

My second PERFECT SHAVE! What can I say? :thumbup:

These are the results I'd always hoped for but never got. Part of it was my technique needed to develop. I had to set aside my 39C slant for two months because I just couldn't handle it without drawing blood. Part was finding the supporting cast: brush, blade, cream/soap and prep. Part was building an objective trial of the razors in my collection. But part was finding the right lead player--my Merkur Futur. All of the above I owe to B&B and this thread in particular (thanks Lou)!

Result #2: Smooth, comfortable, durable, fast and without any irritation at all.

Adjustable Setting: 6.5 (Super Iridium)
Closeness 10
Smoothness 10-defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 10 (3 Pass, no touch-up)
Audible Feedback 10
SC Proraso
AS Tabac

This was accomplished with cold water, per noahpictures (sorry I still don't see the charm).

I looked through my collection last night, and was surprised that I'm willing to part with MOST of it--even my Vision and 39C. Maybe this is an over-reaction, so I'll wait a day or so to think it over.

Codfish

Update: Sweetie had four girlfriends over for lunch, so I decided to give today's shave a field test. The ladies ranged in age from 20 to 50-something and represented a range of experience with men. I asked them to rate my shave on a scale of 1-10. I got a perfect score, with most also adding that it looked REALLY GOOD! Sweetie is less upset with my new purchas now, and is looking forward to me shaving her legs tonight!!!:thumbup::thumbup::thumbup:

brianw

09-22-2010, 10:56 AM

My second PERFECT SHAVE! What can I say? :thumbup:

Sweetie is less upset with my new purchas now, and is looking forward to me shaving her kegs tonight!!!:thumbup::thumbup::thumbup:
I'll drink to that... although aluminum is a bit hard on blades:lol::lol:

brianw

09-22-2010, 11:14 AM

Congrats Codfish....my wife gets at least one straight shave on the legs at least once a week...the paybacks can be very enjoyable:blushing:

noahpictures

09-22-2010, 11:51 AM

This was accomplished with cold water, per noahpictures (sorry I still don't see the charm).

I looked through my collection last night, and was surprised that I'm willing to part with MOST of it--even my Vision and 39C. Maybe this is an over-reaction, so I'll wait a day or so to think it over.

[I][COLOR=Sienna][B][SIZE=3]Codfish

Cold water shaving isn't for everyone. I'll be cold water shaving for at least a couple of days per week. It will be interesting how your third shave with warm water will compare.
Don't give up on the 39C so easily. :thumbup:

DunEdinRanger

09-22-2010, 04:18 PM

Codfish,

I think you should keep the 39C, at least until this experiment is over because that is the next razor!:w00t:

If I had to keep just a handful of DE's, they would be the Futur, the Slants, the 12C, and the Jagger DE 89L.

DunEdinRanger

09-22-2010, 05:01 PM

So what happens when the alarm doesn't go off and you wake up well past your normal time? Well, you don't skip the shave, that's what.

I did shave in much less time than usual, and the results were very, very good. 12 hours later, still BBS. I also used the Pinaud Bay Rum, and while I was expecting to be brought low by the after effects, I was pleasantly surprised as there was no pain.

Adjustable Setting: 6.5 (Red Pack Personna)
Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 10-defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 10.0 (just over 16 minutes) 3 Pass
Audible Feedback 10.0
SS TABAC
AS Pinaud Clubman Virgin Isles Bay Rum

noahpictures

09-22-2010, 05:26 PM

I shaved a bit late and I had plenty of stubble. I shaved with cold water again from start to finish and it felt great. One small nick and a bit of razor burn. After three passes I had a BBS.

Adjustable Setting: 6 (Red Pack Personna)
Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 9.5-defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 6 (24 minutes) 3 Pass Plus
Audible Feedback 10.0
SS TABAC
AS Royall Lyme

I only get three shaves max per blade so this is most likely the last shave with this blade.
Lou, when you're on shave six or seven using the Futur/Personna I might join you for one last shave using the same blade.

I am itching to try the Gillette New OC that has been waiting for me. :biggrin1:

I hate to admit but the Futur is tied with the Slant(s) as my favorite razor.

DunEdinRanger

09-22-2010, 07:13 PM

Noah,

I am hoping that the last shave with this blade will be on 30 September.

noahpictures

09-22-2010, 07:58 PM

Noah,

I am hoping that the last shave with this blade will be on 30 September.

Thanks Lou.

Codfish

09-22-2010, 10:30 PM

DunEdinRanger

09-23-2010, 05:43 PM

Again, another great shave with the Futur. I'm not sure why it took longer than yesterday, but I am not going to argue with the results. BBS, and long lasting. When I started shaving with a DE, over two years ago, I would have been happy with avoiding 5 O'Clock Shadow at 5 PM. I am not spoiled.

Adjustable Setting: 6.5 (Red Pack Personna)
Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 9.8-defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 8.8 (just over 24 minutes) 3 Pass
Audible Feedback 10.0
SS My Time Bath & Body Old School
AS Pinaud Clubman

Codfish

09-24-2010, 10:34 AM

I tried a speed test on shave #3. I dialed it back to "4" and flew through a three-pass shave in less than half the normal time. The shave was very good, but I noticed a scraping feeling on my right cheek. No blood or stinging when I applied Boosters, but tenderness that lasted a day.

My fourth shave was at a "6.5" setting, and was equal to the fantastic shaves I've been getting, even though the blade is not fresh.

Result #4: Smooth, comfortable, durable and without any irritation at all.

Adjustable Setting: 6.5 (Super Iridium)
Closeness 10
Smoothness 10-defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 10 (3 Pass, no touch-up)
Audible Feedback 10
SC Proraso
AS Tabac

I'm beginning to believe I found the set-up that's perfect for me...

Codfish

DunEdinRanger

09-24-2010, 04:34 PM

DunEdinRanger

09-24-2010, 04:44 PM

What happens when you wake up way late? This time, I had to rush through the shave. There was no blood, but there were a few rough spots in the afternoon. It was still BBS when I was done though. And I can only feel those rough spots if I go against the grain.

Adjustable Setting: 6.5 (Red Pack Personna)
Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 9.8-defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 9.8
Time 10.0 (just over 16 minutes) 3 Pass
Audible Feedback 10.0
SC WARS
AS Jickey by Boosters

This lateness is due entirely to the lemma.

Codfish

09-24-2010, 08:11 PM

Sure, you say that now, but the Slant is next...

:::straining at the bit::: OK, let us know when!!!

Codfish

DunEdinRanger

09-25-2010, 04:19 AM

:::straining at the bit::: OK, let us know when!!!

Codfish

No later than 1 October.:w00t:

Codfish

09-25-2010, 07:18 PM

For this shave I tried a two-pass (WTG and ATG). I dialed it to "4.5" and cut my time to about half of normal. I was honestly surprised at the quality and comfort--very near BBS everywhere with no irritation or burning.

Adjustable Setting: 4.5 (Super Iridium)
Closeness 9.5
Smoothness 10-defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10
Time 10 (2 Passes, no touch-up)
Audible Feedback 10
SC Proraso
AS Tabac

This razor and blade combo is awsome...

Codfish

DunEdinRanger

09-25-2010, 07:53 PM

This morning I took my time. I shaved after showering and did not have any time keeping device near me.

I was careful with the passes, and the result was a stellar shave. Well more than 12 hours after the shave, still BBS, still facetur.... well you get the idea.

I'm still amazed that the 6th shave with a blade yielded such great results.

Adjustable Setting: 6.5 (Red Pack Personna)
Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 10-defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time NA - 3 Pass including touch up
Audible Feedback 10.0
SC JM Fraser's Mosswood
AS Mosswood by Boosters

Codfish

09-26-2010, 09:47 AM

I took my time this morning and was pleased with the results. This is my first time with Iridium blades and I am very impressed. I can't detect any noticeable chance in performance since Shave 1. Very sharp and smooth on my skin.

Adjustable Setting: 6.5 (Super Iridium)
Closeness 10
Smoothness 10-defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10
Time 10 (3 Passes, no touch-up)
Audible Feedback 10
SC Proraso
AS Tabac

Codfish

DunEdinRanger

09-26-2010, 10:27 AM

I'm not shaving today, but think I will try an Iridium in the Slant next...

Codfish

09-27-2010, 08:51 AM

The Iridium blade continues to amaze me. Today's shave was world-class. I've never used a blade that I found worked well after five shaves. I'll keep on going with it, at least until the slant road-test begins..

Adjustable Setting: 6.5 (Super Iridium)
Closeness 10
Smoothness 10-defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10
Time 10 (3 Passes, no touch-up)
Audible Feedback 10
SC Proraso
AS Tabac

Codfish

(http://badgerandblade.com/vb/editpost.php?do=editpost&p=2430858)

DunEdinRanger

09-27-2010, 03:44 PM

I shaved this morning with a two day growth. I got up early and too my time with a very light touch. I was lucky in that a friend just returned from Poland with 10 tubes of Wars. :w00t: I gave him one as he was very curious about why I wanted a product that has been made in Poland since before WWII. So, I got to start the week off with a great shave and the great scent of Wars.:001_tt1:

How was the shave? Outstanding! Still smooth and nearly BBS after more than 12 hours. I can't see any stubble, nor is there sign of 5 O'Clock Shadow, but I can feel the whiskers starting to poke out,

And this reminds me of something I wanted to mention. Invisistubble - those whiskers you can't see, but can feel and hear the razor cutting. The Futur does an outstanding job of getting rid of those.

Adjustable Setting: 6.5 (Red Pack Personna)
Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 10-defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 6.0 36 minutes - 3 Pass plus touch up
Audible Feedback 10.0
SC WARS
AS Clubman

Codfish

09-27-2010, 04:20 PM

And this reminds me of something I wanted to mention. Invisistubble - those whiskers you can't see, but can feel and hear the razor cutting. The Futur does an outstanding job of getting rid of those.

I've been grappling with how to describe what's unique about the Futur. That's it exactly!

Codfish

noahpictures

09-27-2010, 05:35 PM

This is a record for me, a comfortable fourth shave using the same razor and blade! A first in my DE shaving experience. I used warm water and was a bit careless with the razor, yet I had a pretty comfortable shave with only a couple of small nicks and a bit of razor burn.

Adjustable Setting: 6 (Red Pack Personna)
Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 9-defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 6.0 25 minutes - 3 Pass plus touch up
Audible Feedback 10.0
SS Tabac
AS Nivea Soothing

I continue to be impressed by the Futur.

Codfish

09-28-2010, 09:09 AM

How do you improve on the perfect shave? You repeat it again and again with the same blade.

Still no noticeable change in the quality of the shave. Just the barest hint of possible dragging (I might be imagining it).

Adjustable Setting: 6.5 (Super Iridium)
Closeness 10
Smoothness 10-defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10
Time 10 (3 Passes, no touch-up)
Audible Feedback 10
SC Proraso
AS Tabac

The Iridium is without doubt the finest blade for my face that I've ever used!

Codfish
(http://badgerandblade.com/vb/editpost.php?do=editpost&p=2433385)

brianw

09-28-2010, 03:20 PM

Hey Lou.... how long until we get to the injector's

noahpictures

09-28-2010, 06:27 PM

Another personal record. Today was really hot (around 100 degrees), so I went with cold water, ice cubes, Proraso Pre, and Proraso shaving cream. I rinsed my face between passes with an ice cube. After three passes and minor touch up I had a BBS in under 20 minutes.
I have never been able to get this many comfortable shaves out of a blade.

Adjustable Setting: 6 (Red Pack Personna)
Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 10-defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 8.0 (19 minutes - 3 Pass plus touch up)
Audible Feedback 10.0
SC Proraso
AS Skin Bracer

Shaving with cold water, and ice cubes feels awesome during 100 plus degree weather.

DunEdinRanger

09-28-2010, 07:37 PM

I shaved out of the shower today, and wanted a very close shave since I had an after work function.

I am still incredulous at how clean shaven I am, even now. I can barely feel any stubble, even along the jaw line.

This time, the Futur has outdone itself. I may keep shaving with this blade until the end of the work week.

Adjustable Setting: 6.5 (Red Pack Personna)
Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 10-defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 8.5- 24 minutes - 3 Pass plus touch up
Audible Feedback 10.0
SS TABAC
AS Booster's Oriental Spice

DunEdinRanger

09-28-2010, 07:39 PM

Hey Lou.... how long until we get to the injector's

Next week is the Slant, and then the Injectors. I figure around Oct 12-13 we should start with an Injector.

brianw

09-28-2010, 07:54 PM

The week of the meetup ???? I'm there

DunEdinRanger

09-28-2010, 07:59 PM

The week of the meetup ???? I'm there

Yuppers, you got it.

Codfish

09-29-2010, 09:36 AM

I don't know what happened overnight, but my blade was nearly un-usable today. Rather than struggle with it, I changed it midway through the first pass.

So far, in my 10 months of wet shaving, the Futur/Iridium combo is the best I've found.

Adjustable Setting: 6.5 (Super Iridium)
Closeness 10
Smoothness 10-defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10
Time 10 (3 Passes, no touch-up)
Audible Feedback 10
SC Proraso
AS Boosters Polar Ice

Codfish
(http://badgerandblade.com/vb/editpost.php?do=editpost&p=2433385)

DunEdinRanger

09-29-2010, 05:35 PM

This was a bit rushed, not withstanding I still took over 20 minutes. This was the 9th shave with the blade and it did feel a little rough, not as smooth as the previous 8 shaves.

Yet 12 hours after the shave, no 5 O'Clock Shadow and nearly BBS. There will be at least one more shave with this razor and blade combo.

Adjustable Setting: 6.5 (Red Pack Personna)
Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 10-defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 8.8- 21 minutes - 3 Pass plus touch up
Audible Feedback 10.0
SC JM Fraser Polar Ice
AS Gentemen's Best CHILLED Siganture Series

noahpictures

09-29-2010, 07:19 PM

I shaved with warm water and didn't prep very well. I could feel the blade tug on the neck and under the nose so I didn't chance touch up. After three passes I had a DFS. Pretty impressive.

Adjustable Setting: 6 (Red Pack Personna)
Closeness 9
Smoothness 9-defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 9
Time 6- 22 minutes - 3 Pass
Audible Feedback 10.0
SS Tabac
AS Gillette balm

DunEdinRanger

09-30-2010, 04:48 PM

This was the tenth shave with the same blade. The net result was a very close, smooth shave with minimal irritation. Even now, there is virtually no stublble that I can feel, or even see.

Adjustable Setting: 6.5 (Red Pack Personna)
Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 10-defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 8.2- 25 minutes - 3 Pass plus touch up
Audible Feedback 10.0
SS TABAC
AS Aqua Velva Classic

noahpictures

09-30-2010, 05:14 PM

Soon I'll be learning to shave with a straight razor. If something goes horribly wrong, I'll come back running to the Slant. :lol:

Thanks Lou.

DunEdinRanger

09-30-2010, 06:05 PM

Soon I'll be learning to shave with a straight razor. If something goes horribly wrong, I'll come back running to the Slant. :lol:

Thanks Lou.

I hope all goes well!

Tomorrow begins the Slant Bar and it will have an Iridium blade. :thumbup1:

Codfish

10-01-2010, 03:59 PM

I experimented a little with my prep by adding a thin layer of Cremo to my wet face, followed by Proraso cream. I then face-lathered as usual. It provided a thick, slick based and a very comfortable shaving experience.

The Iridium blade seems perfect for this razor, as it was for the Futur. A wonderful shave. I like the feel of the 39C in my hand and on my face. It's well-balanced, secure and easily maneuverable.

Blade: Super Iridium
Closeness 10
Smoothness 10-defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10
Time 9 (3 Passes, touch-up on chin)
Audible Feedback 8
SC Cremo/Proraso (layered)
AS Tabac

I think I'll be keeping this razor in my collection after all.

Codfish
(http://badgerandblade.com/vb/editpost.php?do=editpost&p=2433385)

DunEdinRanger

10-01-2010, 05:04 PM

That Super Iridium was so smooth, and glided so easily I did not feel any of the nicks until the evidence appeared. It liked blood as much as a Feather blade; a blade one member described as pure concentrated evil. :lol:

Nonetheless, it was a very close shave, resulting in BBS, and lasting over 12 hours. Judging by feel alone, it feels at this time like a closer shave than the last Futur shave, and certainly at least comparable to the best I received while using the Futur.

Perhaps, it was the first shave. Perhaps it was the bottom of the bowl of the TOBS. Perhaps it was a combination of other factors, but I definitely felt the Clubman sting today.

Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 5.1-defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 6.9- 29 minutes - 3 Pass plus touch up
Audible Feedback 9.8
SC TOBS St. James
AS Clubman by Pinaud

DunEdinRanger

10-02-2010, 04:33 PM

I finished the 2nd shave with the Super Iridium around 4:30.

It was a remarkably close shave. There is no evidence of a whisker evern thinking of peeping out at this time.

But, oh what a bloodthirsty little blade! It rivals the Feather.

DunEdinRanger

10-03-2010, 05:34 AM

This shave was done on Saturday afternoon. It is only now, 16 hours after the shave that I am beginning to feel any kind of stubble. I wouldn't even characterize it as a 5 O'Clock Shadow at this point.

It was close, and effortless, but not without a small price to be paid in blood. And the nicks were all in the last pass; the Against The Grain pass and the touchup where I really go after those hard, tough whiskers.

There will probably be no shaving today.

Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 9.0-defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 8.5- 24 minutes - 3 Pass plus touch up
Audible Feedback 9.8
SC WARS
AS Oriental Spice by Booster

Codfish

10-03-2010, 07:13 PM

Another fantastic shave. It's been 12 hours, and I'm still BBS on 75% of my face. No 5 o'clock shadow anywhere.

The Iridium blade is perfect for me. It glides, it works and it leaves my face intact--if I use zero pressure throughout! Effortless. Feathers are a fraction sharper, but they seem to catch and irritate no matter how light the pressure. YMMV applies, as always.

I found these blades by reading Squire's post on another board: SMF :: View topic - Squire's Blade Reviews (http://www.shavemyface.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=29705&postdays=0&postorder=asc&start=0). I recommend this post to those who have not yet found the blade that works best for them.

Blade: Super Iridium
Closeness 10
Smoothness 10-defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10
Time 8 (4 Passes)
Audible Feedback 9
SC Cremo/Proraso (layered)
AS Tabac

Codfish
(http://badgerandblade.com/vb/editpost.php?do=editpost&p=2433385)

DunEdinRanger

10-04-2010, 03:26 PM

I understand there is a saying in Germany, "He who tastes blood, gets to like it." This Iridium Blade has certainly developed a taste for it! :lol: It was nothing that needed a Styptic Pencil, but there were lots of little red dots.

The shave? Incredibly smooth, long lasting as now, more than 12 hours after shaving, I am still mostly BBS.

Once again, like the Futur I have to note that this razor is very good at getting rid of the "invisistubble", the whiskers that you can hear it cut, buit are not visible.

Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 9.8-defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 29 minutes - 3 Pass plus touch up
Audible Feedback 10.0
SS TABAC
AS Stephan Bay Rum

Codfish

10-04-2010, 04:52 PM

Terrific shave, and long-lasting. My concentration lapsed for a fraction of a second, though, and I got a nick as a result. Not bad enough to need alum, and the only spot I noticed mild stinging when I applied Tabac.

I have a feeling that the blade will not last eight shaves as it did in the Futur.

Blade: Super Iridium
Closeness 10
Smoothness 9-defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10
Time 9 (3 Passes, no touch-up)
Audible Feedback 9
SC Cremo/Proraso (layered)
AS Tabac

Codfish
UPDATE: I may take tomorrow off. I just received a new, unused Stahly Live Blade and I think I'll take it for a test ride!

DunEdinRanger

10-05-2010, 04:51 PM

So, today I shaved after a morning shower. I did not have a problem lathering following the advice given in the forums, and it produced a nice, thick, rich lather.

The end result? More than 12 hours after shaving, still mainly BBS with just some stubble being felt along the right jawline.

Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 9.8-defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 24 minutes - 3 Pass plus touch up
Audible Feedback 10.0
SS Mitchell's Wool Fat
AS Jickey by Booster

jgriffith

10-06-2010, 08:20 AM

DunEdinRanger

10-06-2010, 05:26 PM

Lou,
Just curious... was this something different than your normal lathering procedure? Also, did it seem to quench the slants thirst for blood on this shave?

I made the lather as described in threads here, since I had heard MWF can be pretty tough to lather. I didn't have a problem. Normally, I don't drain as much water out of the brush as I do for MWF.

It's not the Slant's thirst for blood, but the Super Iridium, and it has apparently been sated.

DunEdinRanger

10-06-2010, 05:32 PM

I stuck with what worked yesterday, but this time I had showered the night before.

I had one of the closest, smoothest shaves ever. It is only now, more than 14 hours after shaving that I am even beginning to feel some stubble along the jawline. Pretty much BBS everywhere else.

The MWF may have also sated the blade's thirst for blood.

Although, I have to say, when I awoke this morning, I thought I did not need to shave. Then when I started, I received the audible feedback that said even though I could not see the stubble, the razor was mowing it down. And it did, quite efficiently.

Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 9.8-defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 25 minutes - 3 Pass plus touch up
Audible Feedback 10.0
SS Mitchell's Wool Fat
AS Jickey by Booster

jgriffith

10-06-2010, 08:51 PM

Codfish

10-07-2010, 05:51 PM

One of the unexpected by-product of participating in this forum seems to be that I may have picked up shaving skills without really thinking about it.

Case in point: my Sledgehammer does a better job than it did a few months ago. Part may be that I discovered Iridium blades recently, but my instincts tell me that the concentration required to adapt to new razors helped me pick up a lot of good experience in a relatively short time.

Bottom line: I am happier with my equipment and results than I've ever been.

Today's shave was terrific, smooth and long-lasting. No irritation at all.

Blade: Super Iridium
Closeness 10
Smoothness 10-defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10
Time 10 (3 Passes and touch-up) I timed it for once (12 minutes)
Audible Feedback 9
SC Cremo/Proraso (layered)
AS Boosters Polar Ice

Codfish

DunEdinRanger

10-07-2010, 06:38 PM

The Lemma in her yearly travels wreaks havoc with my circadian rythm. We are now at the point in the calendar where, in the northeast, we're waking up in the dark. That means I don't think it's time to get up. :lol:

So anyway, I was definitely rushed today. Despite that, still very smooth and close. Once again, I thought I could skip shaving if I had to, but shaved anyway. And once again, I was impressed with how much stubble was removed by the Slant.

Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 9.9 -defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time19 minutes - 3 Pass including touch up
Audible Feedback 10.0
SS TABAC
AS Mosswood by Booster

DunEdinRanger

10-07-2010, 06:41 PM

Ahhh... thanks for the clarification and the notes on MWF. I've been following your posts closely and waiting patiently for the "week of the slant" (you almost killed me extending the Futur for a week). I have the EJ, RedTip and Mergress with my eye on the slant next.

After all the posts, you want a Mergress and not a Futur? :tongue_sm

Thanks for being a reader of these posts. I hope they have been informative, at the least.

How would you rate the EJ vs. the Red Tip?

jgriffith

10-07-2010, 08:29 PM

Codfish

10-08-2010, 11:26 AM

Your postings (as well as those by codfish) have been very informative and useful for me. I appreciate the effort both of you have put forth in documenting your shaves. I'll be selling the Mergress and purchasing a Sledge I'm pretty sure.

This has been a great learning experience for me. I've learned more than I expected through this hands-on process.

I don't think you'll be disappointed in a slant. I rank my 39C right along with the Futur.

Codfish

DunEdinRanger

10-08-2010, 05:39 PM

I went with the MWF again, today despite it being Tabactober, and while still an MWF noob, I continue to be impressed by the soap and the rich lather it produces.

This was after showering so the stubble was well hydrated. The net result was an extremely close shave, staying at BBS levels for well over 12 hours.

There was some initial irritation after applying the AS around the neck, but that was it.

Closeness 10.0
Smoothness 9.8 -defined as lack of irritation immediately following the shave.
Durability 10.0
Time 21 minutes - 3 Pass plus touch up
Audible Feedback 10.0
SS Mitchell's Wool Fat
AS Oriental Spice by Booster

brianw

10-08-2010, 06:16 PM

Lou .... You seem to be a boosters lover.... any comparisons to another ..... and where do you buy it

DunEdinRanger

10-08-2010, 06:23 PM

I obtained the mergress, but I should've waited for the posting on the Futur :(
I have to say that out of the three (including the Red Tip) I've gone back to the EJ. Something about it just seems to work very well for me. The Red Tip was nice, much "faster" shave, but I seemed to get a closer shave with the EJ. I would put the EJ ahead of the RedTip, and even the Mergress at 4 1/2. Something about the EJ, it always seems to give a comfortable shave with minimal irritation.

Your postings (as well as those by codfish) have been very informative and useful for me. I appreciate the effort both of you have put forth in documenting your shaves. I'll be selling the Mergress and purchasing a Sledge I'm pretty sure.

Thanks for the comments. I would also rate the EJ ahead of the Red Tip, and it certainly gave me a smoother shave.

Lou .... You seem to be a boosters lover.... any comparisons to another ..... and where do you buy it

Brian, besides Pasteur's, the only other place that I know of carrying Boosters here in the states is West Coast Shaving.

The Jickey smells like English Leather to me.

I have no comparisons for Mosswood :001_wub::001_wub: or the Oriental Spice.