Your Favorite Scotch

[TimmyBoston]

What is your favorite Scotch? What's the best you've been able to get your hands on?

For me, It would have to be Highland Park 25. Definately Highland Park 25. It was gorgeous.

Followed up by White Horse Lagavulin 16.

My favorite daily drinkers are: HP 12, Laphroaig 15, and Talisker 18.

[jakuda]

Bowmore 25, but I could live on Lagavulin 16.

[Doc4]

Talisker 10 ... no, Lagavulin 16 ... no, Laphroaig ... no, Cragganmore ... the Macallan ...

[jazzman]

:thumbup: The Balvenie New Wood
The Balvenie Double Wood

[knlgskr]

Port Magdalene 25, Port Ellen (if you can find it--closed). I don't care much for blends--Scotch or Irish. If I wanted grain whisky, I would drink Vodka. There is a Malt Maniac webpage written by a gentleman in Holland that covers many malts and seems objective if one can be objective in regard to whisky. I definitely prefer malt whiskies but don't use chlorinated water added or on the side with them.

[180gVinyl]

Macallan 18 and Springbank 21

:drool:

[BroJohn]

Lagavulin.

-- John Gehman

[boboakalfb]

Lagavulin 16.

I have been wanting to pick up a book on Whisk(e)y. What would you guys recommend? Something by Michael Jackson?

[TimmyBoston]

I have been wanting to pick up a book on Whisk(e)y. What would you guys recommend? Something by Michael Jackson?

Complete Guide to Single Malt Scotch: A Connoisseurs's Guide to the Single Malt's of Scotland by Michael Jackson. It's a wonderful book and definately the book, I'd recommend.

[analog_kid]

The Macallan 12, but considering I'm a scotch newb, I've only tried 3 different scotchs. I'm sure I'll find something I like better every week!

[murchmb]

Caol Ila is the best I've ever had. Don't remember the age, but probably the 12. A friend living in the UK brought some to a small gathering. I've never seen a bottle of liquor disappear so quickly, at least since I got out of college. :smile:

[Doc4]

The Macallan 12, but considering I'm a scotch newb, I've only tried 3 different scotchs. I'm sure I'll find something I like better every week!

That's pretty good for your third scotch! You'll have to work hard to top that.

[knlgskr]

My mistake the address is: maltmadness.com; also whisky.com

[johnniegold]

Blend: Johnnie Gold 18 year old

Single Malt: Oban 14 year old

[ratcheer]

The Balvenie 15 year old single barrel.

Tim

[JaDubb]

Lagavulin 16 is nice, but even more I prefer Laphroaig 10 YO Cask Strength. Less medicinal version (in taste) of standard Laphroaig 10 YO.

[Greatgoo]

Do you guys just drink this straight? :scared:

[JaDubb]

Do you guys just drink this straight? :scared:

I'd have exactly the same reaction, if I'd hear that someone would mix his scotch with anything else but a little amount of purified water. Even that purified water is sometimes too much of a mixer. :tongue_sm

[Doc4]

Do you guys just drink this straight? :scared:

I like my scotch like my razor ... stright, and raised to my face a dozen times a day!

[Adair]

Royal Lochnagar
and
Glenfarclas

[180gVinyl]

I'd have exactly the same reaction, if I'd hear that someone would mix his scotch with anything else but a little amount of purified water. Even that purified water is sometimes too much of a mixer. :tongue_sm

The only appropriate answer to the question:

"Do you want anything with it?"

Is..............................................





Another one



:biggrin:


Neat......................... Just like Cary Grant

[TimmyBoston]

Do you guys just drink this straight? :scared:

Only way to drink it.

[TVguy15]

Lagavulin, Glenmorangie Port Wood casked, laphroaig 10...yummy stuff

[Legato]

Glenlivet 15 French Oak Reserve.

Yum.

[JBHoren]

I like my scotch like my razor ... stright, and raised to my face a dozen times a day!

I like my women like my whiskey... 12 years-old and mixed-up with Coke!

But seriously, folks; I only drink my Scotch straight-up. Why would I want to dilute a perfectly good tumbler of spirits, with water, or cool it with ice?

Also: I vote for Lagavulin, but more often than not, I drink Teacher's (a very drinkable blended whiskey, equally good by itself, or in a cuppa coffee).

[BenWorld]

Laphroaig.

The 15 year is a treat, but the CASK STRENGTH is giddy joy!

No matter what I put Laphroaig up against, it wins.

[timsackbutt]

Resurrecting this thread...

Caol Ila 18 yr old. All the best attributes of Islay malts with smoothness.

And very partial to Ardbeg, even the 10 yr old

[MTgrayling]

Being a new Scotch drinker the best I've had, so far, is Glenfiddich. Wonderfully smooth stuff that's in my price range. Does anyone have any advice for climbing up the Glenfiddich ladder? I'm thinking of trying a bottle of 15yo next.

[boboakalfb]

Being a new Scotch drinker the best I've had, so far, is Glenfiddich. Wonderfully smooth stuff that's in my price range. Does anyone have any advice for climbing up the Glenfiddich ladder? I'm thinking of trying a bottle of 15yo next.

My advice? Do it. They are much better than the 12.

[Eighties]

Blended: Johnny Walker Blue Label (I can only afford to buy it on vacation)

Single Malt: Glenmoranjie Sherry Oak Finish (It's like nectar)

I prefer my scotch neat.

-80s

[behrendprof]

+1 on the Balvenie Doublewood

The 10 yr old MacAllan is a surprising malt - definitely worth a try and a reasonable buy as well (if you can find it)

I'm interested in Talisker but can't find a bar that serves it around here and I'd like to try before I buy.

[TimmyBoston]

I'm interested in Talisker but can't find a bar that serves it around here and I'd like to try before I buy.

Check out restaurants, not bars, especially steakhouses. It's part of the Diageo's Classic Malts, so you should be able to find it.

[mace]

I'll keep it simple.....Islay:w00t:

The one i hope to open before i die, Millburn Old Malt Cask 1967:lol:

Mind You! There's a whole continent full of wonderfull tipple, tipple we find hard to get hold of and oh-so miss over here:mad3:

Rye...Bourbon...Corn....You know what i'm talking about:tongue_sm

:smile:mace

[KWE]

Single Malt - Lagavulin (As good as the current offering is, I've been told it use to be even better. Sadly, I'll never find that out for myself. Neat is the only way to go with this one.)

Blend - Cutty Sark (Certainly a different flavor profile than Lagavulin, but there is just something about CS that I find very refreshing. I enjoy it on the rocks during the summer. A great one to gulp.)

A close second in the single malt category would have to be Highland Park 18. This is another one I enjoy neat. An outstanding whisky!

Timmy, have you tried HP 18? If so, how does it compare with HP 25? I've been told there is much difference between the two.

[Greyfox]

Oban if there is no good Kentucky bourbon to be had:lol:

[Skydryv]

Ooooh, this is a dangerous thread for me; must contain myself lest I wax long and poetic on one of God's greatest gift to Man (and a few really cool chicks): Single Malt Scotch.

This list is applicable to scothes commonly available. Oh, and please pardon the spelling mistakes. If I go to my bar to check the labels I'll inevitably HAVE to have a few drams...and later today my yard will look crazy from my drunk-mowing.

Here goes.

Breakfast: Dalwhinne

Lunch: Oban

Dinner: McCallan 15 or Talisker

Apres Dinner: Lagavulin 16. Always.

Newest find: Scapa. An Islay with nice peat, a bit of salt air, and a delayed peppery finish (but not too peppery). Very tasty.

Now, if I really wanted to get going, I'd write about Single CASK scotches I get via the SMWS (Single Malt Whiskey Society) or, even, about tastings from the vaults at Leith. But I won't. My laptop battery would die before I was halfway finished.

Ken
Unabashed Scotch SNOB --and proud of it, by God!

Ps. No, I don't really have a dram with my morning cherrioes or noontime PB&J. "Breakfast" etc. for me just refers to the lightness or less serious / contemplative mood of the scotch. Uh Oh, now I'm getting started....must quit now!

[ratcheer]

Oban if there is no good Kentucky bourbon to be had:lol:

It amazes me that even here in Alabama, it is easier to find high-end scotch than high-end bourbon. We used to have Rock Hill Farms, Pappy Van Winkle, etc, but it is all gone from the shelves, now. It is a strict ABC state. :frown:

Tim

[Skydryv]

Pardon the sentimentality, I'm just thinking how cool it is to have tapped into Brethren who are interested in the finer things on the fringes of this life.

We are all "Sucking the Pap and Marrow of Life", shall we say?? Well, from taking one's time in the classic tradition of a man's morning ritual to savoring the slow satisfaction of a Malt thousands of years in the making...I'd say the answer to that question is a resounding "YES".

It's a rare thing, my friends, to find fellows around my age (35) who can --and want to-- appreciate many things beyond the Mach 3 or Dewars White Label (or Bud Light or Pop Music or Post 1980 films or etc., etc., etc). Certainly I have good buds like that and am okay with it. Still, I'm glad I found y'all.

Heaven help us were we ever to all get together in person!

Carry on, good Sirs, Carry on.

Ken

[Slingblade]

Johnnie black and Talisker 25?

been to long to remember they year.

[TimmyBoston]

Timmy, have you tried HP 18? If so, how does it compare with HP 25? I've been told there is much difference between the two.

I have had both. I am a fan of the entire HP line, they produce outstanding whisky all around. Right now in the under $100 market there is nothing better than HP 18. The 25 runs around $300 a bottle, a huge price jump and there is also a big jump in quality, it's not just the extra 7 years in oak, the whisky that is chosen to age that long is the best casks the distillery has to offer. There is a lot of difference, but the additional $200 is hard to swing, which is why I don't own a bottle of the 25. The best way I can put it is that the 18 has much more in common with the 12 than the 25.


As for Lagavulin, I have bottles of the old and the new. There is a tremendous difference, honestly I'm not overly impressed with the new, especially considering it's reputation. I would rate the new an 89 (out of 100) not as good as Laphroaig 15, while I would rate the old at a 95, right up there with HP 25. A truly remarkable whisky.

For those of you interested in trying the old, check out Ebay, often mini's the White Horse crop up for sale at a reasonable cost.

[Telecastick]

How do you answer that question? I'll drink Cutty or Lauders if it comes to it. Currentily I have: Sheep Dip 8 Year, Ardbeg 10, Laphroaig 10, Lagavulin 16, Glenrothers 1987 Vintage, Balvenie Doublewood 12, Balvenie Portwood 21, and an unopened Rosebank 1965 given to me upon my grandfathers death.

All I have to say is, you have to respect the Sheep Dip.

[KWE]

Thanks, Timmy!

[timsackbutt]

Picked up a new one yesterday. Glenrothes 12 yr old. A fine Speyside, quite spicy and malty with a very smooth finish. Enjoyed it very much.

Just finished off the Caol Ila 18 yr old. Will miss it sorely but can't afford another (it was an airport duty free item, 1 litre).

[GAR]

I've bought a couple bottles of Dewar's 12 year old blend and it's mighty good. Affordable, too, at less than $30. Much, much better than their standard blend.

[ScottS]

An old friend of mine named his dog Dewars. It's my favorite blend.

[Kbennett]

Ardbeg and Laphroig. Any years.