Ginger or Mary Ann

[Blondie]

Maybe this has been covered, but what are your thoughts? Me, I'm greedy.

[Little Joe from Mexico]

Forget the glamour. I'm a down-home, old-fashioned kinda guy.

[Telecaster52]

tough one... i agree 100% with joe, but i'm a sucker for a redhead :laugh:

[blackfoot]

It has been a while since we had this fight. I got to go with Mary Ann. :thumbup:

[GoldenMonkey]

Both, please...

[DunEdinRanger]

Normally, I'd say Mary Ann. But, hey it's a desert island, Thurston has his hands full, the professor has his toys, and the Skipper & Gilligan - well let's not go there.

So someone has to step up to the plate and make sure both ladies are *ahem* enjoying island life, let's say.

[KeNd0]

I`ve got a thing for redheads. I blame too many Charlie Brown cartoons as a kid.

[DSB]

Mary Ann by a mile.

[Topgumby]

Mrs. Howell.

She'll be dead soon, and she's loaded!

[wilsonent]

When I was growing up, I was a Ginger guy. Now, got to go with Mary Ann.

[jjjackso]

mary ann. mmmm.

[Walter Sobchak]

It's Mary Ann for me. High attractiveness quotient, low maintenance quotient.

[Walt Whitman]

Mary Ann and Ginger...

while I watch.

When they're done doin' their thing, they come over and do my (ahem) :thumbup:

[Leche]

I pick yellow, Mary Ann, girl next door.
http://lancemannion.typepad.com/photos/uncategorized/russelljohnson6.jpg

[theperfectstorm]

Mary Ann and Ginger...

while I watch.

When they're done doin' their thing, they come over and do my (ahem) :thumbup:

Ironically, the real Walt Whitman would be wholly uninterested in the entire proceedings.

The funny thing about this whole concept is that most of us have thought about this, I mean really analytically, thought about this, several times during our lives. In the real, scientific, objective, serious way that only the man-brain can achieve when approaching the metaphysics of banging fictional characters.

Point is that we have all drawn this out so far in our own heads that when it comes time to reply to a post like this we have to spend much more time thinking about what NOT to say than answering the question. Hence the short pithy replies.

Oh. Right.

Mary-Ann.

[DESkydiver]

My aunt and Tina Louise use to be roommates as starving actresses off-Broadway back in the 50's.

[warlandsboy]

LOL! I'm the only one that's voted "who are these people"...

[Blondie]

Ok, fess up, who modified my post? Has to be one of the mods, right?

[JPM]

Mary-Ann was way hotter! Pig tails and Daisy Dukes do it for me. :w00t:

[Topgumby]

I think that the mods, by introducing the term "little buddy" into a "Ginger or Mary Ann" thread, are accessories before the fact.

[airplanedoc]

So the question is

http://2.bp.blogspot.com/_6-IIXAF5HOE/SZJq7gbjyII/AAAAAAAAE3U/igttg1qCB1w/s400/tinaLouise27-IV-2008.jpg

Vs.

http://www.hilaryshepherd.com/rantsnraves/wp-content/uploads/2008/03/dawn-wells.jpg

[Jim B.]

Always liked redheads and even married one. However, Ginger was a little too flashy and high maintenance for me. Mary Ann was much cuter and more down to earth.

[JPM]

So the question is

http://2.bp.blogspot.com/_6-IIXAF5HOE/SZJq7gbjyII/AAAAAAAAE3U/igttg1qCB1w/s400/tinaLouise27-IV-2008.jpg

Vs.

http://www.hilaryshepherd.com/rantsnraves/wp-content/uploads/2008/03/dawn-wells.jpg

Oh you had to go there. Mr. Buzz-kill! :lol:

[blackfoot]

Ironically, the real Walt Whitman would be wholly uninterested in the entire proceedings.

The funny thing about this whole concept is that most of us have thought about this, I mean really analytically, thought about this, several times during our lives. In the real, scientific, objective, serious way that only the man-brain can achieve when approaching the metaphysics of banging fictional characters.

Point is that we have all drawn this out so far in our own heads that when it comes time to reply to a post like this we have to spend much more time thinking about what NOT to say than answering the question. Hence the short pithy replies.

Oh. Right.

Mary-Ann.

:lol::lol::lol::lol:

This is too funny, if not true. :blush:


Oh you had to go there. Mr. Buzz-kill! :lol:

+1 :thumbdown :lol:

[theperfectstorm]

If you are like me and know the story behind Mary Ann's mug-shot there that only exponentially increases her desirability, not lowers it.

[Greyfox]

Mary Ann. I prefer simply pleasures.

[Gambrinus]

I:001_wub:redheads!! I married one:biggrin1:

[richmondesi]

This discussion was handled well, here (http://trololololololololololo.com/)... :thumbup1:

[Alacrity59]

Mary-Ann. Before you ask Betty Rubble over Wilma Flintstone and Betty over Veronica from the Archie comics.

[Stubblefield]

Mary-Ann. Before you ask Betty Rubble over Wilma Flintstone and Betty over Veronica from the Archie comics.And Linda McCartney over Yoko Ono.

[luvmysuper]

Always liked redheads and even married one. However, Ginger was a little too flashy and high maintenance for me. Mary Ann was much cuter and more down to earth.

Quit destroying my adolescent memories!!!


This discussion was handled well, here (http://trololololololololololo.com/)... :thumbup1:

Ok. I want that 5 minutes back.

I was 3/4 the way through it before I realized that is was a sick version of badger-badger-badger-mushroom-mushroom, and that there would be no point to it!

:lol:


And Linda McCartney over Yoko Ono.

Mrs. Howell over Yoko Ono

[OldSaw]

As a red head I am naturally attracted to the red head. However, (there's always a however) the Mary Ann, "made you a banana cream pie", personality takes the cake. But I had to abstain from voting in favor of the woman who snuggled up next to me while I took a nap today, that would be my beloved bride.

[Legion]

My theory was always that the professor intentionally sabotaged the boat.

No... wait... hear me out...

See, back "in the world" he was just this geek. Hanging around the university, checking out all the hot girls, but basically not getting any action because he was a nerdy professor.

So, he's on vacation and he finds himself on a three hour cruise with not one but two hot girls. What to do? Three hours is not nearly enough time to get anywhere with these two. They are both out of his league. Just then a storm comes up and he has a epiphany. While everybody is distracted, it would be pretty easy to slip away and disable the boat. He would know the flow of the tides, etc. He would know that they would drift ashore somewhere. And with 1960's search and rescue methods it would be pretty easy to stay hidden for as long as he needs.

He would also know that the millionaire is married with his wife present, effectively putting him out of the game. The skipper and "Little Buddy", well.... So he has a pretty clear run at both of the single ladies!

I mean, come on! The guy can build a telephone exchange out of coconuts but he can't fix a boat? Yeah, right... :wink2:

[JPM]

And Linda McCartney over Yoko Ono.

Ok, was there ever any question about that one? :wacko::lol:

[Stubblefield]

Mrs. Howell over Yoko OnoGood one. I won't up the ante. :w00t:

[OldSaw]

And Linda McCartney over Yoko Ono.


Ok, was there ever any question about that one? :wacko::lol:

If only two women are left on the whole planet and one of them is Yoko Ono, it's the other one, no matter how homely she may be.

[JPM]

If only two women are left on the whole planet and one of them is Yoko Ono, it's the other one, no matter how homely she may be.

I'm with ya on that one. She hit every branch on the way down.

[SRock]

Mary Ann was definitely cuter. In my single days I'd say why be choosey and go for both. These days I say neither, I'll take my wife.

[Argonaut]

I`ve got a thing for redheads. I blame too many Charlie Brown cartoons as a kid.

Got a thing for Peppermint Patty do ya?:lol:







Yes I know it's in reference to the "little red haired girl". Maybe.

[RayH]

Voted Mary Ann. But I wouldn't turn Ginger away either.

[wilsonent]

As a red head I am naturally attracted to the red head. However, (there's always a however) the Mary Ann, "made you a banana cream pie", personality takes the cake. But I had to abstain from voting in favor of the woman who snuggled up next to me while I took a nap today, that would be my beloved bride.

I too prefer my bride over either Ginger or Mary Ann. Yes my bride....Morgan Fairchild,.....whom I sleep with.

[DFrancis]

Mary-Ann. Before you ask Betty Rubble over Wilma Flintstone and Betty over Veronica from the Archie comics.

+1 :thumbup1:

[moodymick]

hmm.. apparently this is a thing called 'Gilligans Island', but i have never seen it. i'll take the one with red hair!!

[thunderball]

Mrs. Howell obviously.

http://i154.photobucket.com/albums/s257/nuskool73/3196806411_7cf4a1e13b.jpg

[coolbluewater]

It's not about maintenance, girl next door, etc but it IS about that smokin' bod, and since it's not SWMBO asking:

GINGER. :w00t:

[Haber Dashing]

Both are very lovely. If both were a choice for the single man, then I would say it would just depend on the mood.

[luvmysuper]

I was always just a little disappointed that Gladys Ormphby wasn't on the boat.
Rrrrawwrrrr!!!!:001_tt1:

[gollum83]

Mary Ann was definitely cuter. In my single days I'd say why be choosey and go for both. These days I say neither, I'll take my wife.

She's right behind you, isn't she Rob?

[blackfoot]

She's right behind you, isn't she Rob?

:lol::lol:

[Doc4]

Just wait until the new GI movie comes out ... then we get to compare 'new Ginger' to 'old Ginger' (no one re-quote that post from above :bored:), 'new Mary Anne' to 'old Mary Anne', 'new Ginger' to 'old Mary Anne" ... &c. ...

and then of course the final conclusion ...


Five-way. :thumbup1:







Can I lock the thread now?

[BEAR DEN]

The last time this was debated I thought it was agreed that the correct answer is....both while Mrs. Howell watched.

[SRock]

Just wait until the new GI movie comes out ... then we get to compare 'new Ginger' to 'old Ginger' (no one re-quote that post from above :bored:), 'new Mary Anne' to 'old Mary Anne', 'new Ginger' to 'old Mary Anne" ... &c. ...

and then of course the final conclusion ...


Five-way. :thumbup1:







Can I lock the thread now?

:lol::lol::lol::lol::lol:

[shavervinnie]

Mary Ann (reminds me of my wife :thumbup1:)

[blackfoot]

Mary Ann (reminds me of my wife :thumbup1:)

So, you voted Ginger then? :lol: J/K

[htownmmm]

Mary Ann of course. Ginger has ' the look', but Mary Ann has 'the body'.


marty

[Blondie]

Alright, now you have gone too far. First we add lovey, skipper and little buddy. Now we have art is king in there. The scientific integrity of this poll has now been completely compromised, as has my doctorate thesis.

Great, now I'm never gonna get it done.

:lol::lol:

[Doc4]

So the question is

[photo deleted for sanity]

Vs.

[photo also deleted for sanity]


dude ... time machine ... duh!

[blackfoot]

I like the new edit. :lol:

[GDCarrington]

Pf9Kt5t4QhM

Don't rush me ... hurry up now!

[pz93c]

All three in any order..... or at once.

Little Buddy can watch.

[GDCarrington]

Mary Ann Regrets

XcyjY3DgF3c

[tvldatsi]

wow mary ann crushes! gotta go with both, blondes are best, so neither of these two can be real winners :biggrin:

[GDCarrington]

70TcOd6gwgw

[GDCarrington]

Please don't forget about the king!

So much for the king. 1 measly vote!

[GDCarrington]

k400prJh43E

[GDCarrington]

To clear up any issues this is not the right Ginger!
This a completely different Ginger!

ubLodboW_4Q

[livingontheedge]

Mary Ann then Ginger then Mary Ann

[timsclips]

Didn't I read at one time that before filming started that Raquel Welch was considered for Mary Ann?

Okay, now, Raquel or Tina?

[maxman]

I'm more of a Mary Ann man, but Ginger just has something that I can't put my finger on. Some kind of je ne sais quoi.

[GDCarrington]

I'm more of a Mary Ann man, but Ginger just has something that I can't put my finger on. Some kind of je ne sais quoi.

Well if you did put your finger on it, you might find out this:

AMFMf9cN64U

[grump]

Variety, you will never know unless you try them.

[GDCarrington]

o99t5Sv_kZw

[Charles Darwin]

Mary-Anne was EASILY my first "celebrity crush" as a kid. She has a special place in my heart.

[Dennard]

Mary Ann.

[Topgumby]

UWO6f4ugZPs

Better than Brandy, by the way.

[Johnny Dale]

Mary Ann! but Ginger would do in a pinch! :lol:

[GDCarrington]

Mary Ann! but Ginger would do in a pinch! :lol:

If you pinch her she might just shoulder tackle you! :w00t:

QHxwjsjJRhY

[GDCarrington]

The Shadows - 'Mary Anne'

pnwAXAmiQ3k

[pal]

Just Ginger!

[GDCarrington]

Just Ginger!

For you Pal

lL9YIpp_rlk

[GDCarrington]

Ginger Baker's Airforce - Sunshine Of Your Love

7eC3NRRRi9Q

[GDCarrington]

Mary Ann Walking Away

5WTcHHwBB_0

[Jasonian]

Oh you had to go there. Mr. Buzz-kill! :lol:
It's not a buzz-kill! Here's why.

Those are the actresses who formerly played the roles of Ginger and Mary Ann.

Ginger and Mary Ann, however, are characters of a general age, characteristics, and appearances. The actresses no longer embody necessary characteristics to fulfill the roles of the characters.

The characters remain attractive. The actresses who once played their roles.. well, that's subjective isn't it?

[Doc4]

Didn't I read at one time that before filming started that Raquel Welch was considered for Mary Ann?

Okay, now, Raquel or Tina?

I'll see your Raquel Welch as Marry Ann, and raise you a Sophia Loren as Ginger.

[GDCarrington]

I'll see your Raquel Welch as Mary Ann, and raise you a Sophia Loren as Ginger.

Nice stakes!

[GDCarrington]

Ginger "Solid Ground"

A0TsWDKLNqQ

[GDCarrington]

Ain't She Sweet

-ltzEygYw2s

[GDCarrington]

Tina Louise Tribute

60mC7cmP278

[GDCarrington]

Ginger Gets Hypnotized

Llcj_QRkVeU

[GDCarrington]

Hypnotizing Mary Ann

Sdf3RAKu-TI

[GDCarrington]

Ophelia's Song from Gilligan's Island's version of Hamlet

m4qRWsgxssA

Note the appearance of Harold Hecuba!

[GDCarrington]

Ginger vs. Mary Ann

YMQHIQFgYXs

[Cheesehead Transplant]

I'm married to a red head so I'll go with Mary Ann. Lucky for me, my wife doesn't go to B&B.

[GDCarrington]

Mary Ann

obk8iF94SeQ

[Sir Sartana]

As much as I like redheads, it has to be Mary Ann,girl next door gets the nod.

[GDCarrington]

New and Improved!

6tIuSsZoYJ0

[GDCarrington]

Meet Dawn Wells aka Mary Ann from Gilligan's Island LIVE!

cFt1jJPQ-K8

[GDCarrington]

IzIrObe3IbQ