- Most menthol-y splash?
- Bay rums
- Floid Blue
- substitute of Weleda?
- where to buy Humphreys witch hazel
- Making Aftershave - A Few Questions
- Aftershave Balm = Whole Face lotion?
- Proraso replacement?
- thayers rose witch hazel
- 444
- Alt Innsbruck
- Pierre Cardin Aftershave Balm
- Thayer's WH scent opinions?
- Tabac & Jovan Musk
- Aftershave Balm Recipe?
- There's just something about an Aqua
- Antique Lilac Vegetal
- Think I'm in Trouble!!!
- So I'm enjoying a Red Stripe Beer...
- Tried a few new (to me) products this week
- Which Witch Hazel ???
- Need moisturizing ASB or Cream
- Master AS products.
- Florida Water in the glass bottle
- Dallas supplier.
- What is vegetal
- Looking for something unscented to follow up a splash?
- Gillette Cool Wave AS
- After shave splashes.
- Mixed Feelings on Pinaud Lime Sec
- i've been chosen!
- Clubman
- Found an old Globe
- "Designer" aftershaves?
- Thinking about adding PS
- If you had to choose one...
- Glass Pinaud Bottles
- Tried Proraso For The 1st Time Today!
- Check this out.
- How not to spill AS while traveling - your thoughts?
- Thayers in europe?
- Spain (myrsol question)
- Adding bay tree essential oil to Pinaud bay rum?
- Happy 4711! (4-7-11) PIF
- New Pinaud Special Reserve label?
- English Leather
- I love Clubman, what other AS should add to my rotation?
- Frozen head.
- Marco - most authentic Italian Barbershop Splash
- Can anyone recommended a scentless ASB?
- Hâttric Vs. Alt-Innsbruck : most healing/moisturizing ?
- Homemade Trumper's Skin Food!
- Honeybee Gardens Herbal Bay Rum AS is Good Stuff!
- Why do you prefer splash-ons over balms?
- MARAVELLA witch hazel
- A recent convert to Clubman...
- What compares to Master Bay Rum?
- Does all bay rum smell like cloves?
- My brain hurts
- Geo F. trumper Sampler
- Best place to get Osage Rub online?
- Long Lasting Aftershave splash
- I've been chosen!
- about to brew my own bar rum, got some
- Help with aftershave balm
- Green Green & Green
- Making my own mentholated lime AS
- Substitute for GFT Skin Food....
- Japanese Bay Rum Aftershaves?
- Trying to find an inexpensivce AS that SWMBO agrees with
- What’s Your Minimum Stand Up And Fight For Them Number of AS’s?
- Florida Water
- Clubman makes me smell like a Baby...
- Bay Rum samples?
- Can't email Saint Charles Shave
- What's the point of glycerin in AS
- 4711 sale
- An Aftershave Balm/Splash Primer
- Haiku for Pinaud PIF!
- diffrence between aftershave and cologne
- My Rant on Finding Shaving products
- Lubriderm 3 in 1 Lotion
- Best Clubman Review
- Cheap Post Shave Moisturizing
- Gift from Belize
- 3P Pre/Post
- Mattface's Bay Rum Recipe
- Aftershave splash/blam for oily / combo skin
- How many bottles of SCS A/S do you have?
- Interesting combo.. Sandalwood+The Veg
- Speick Splash + Eton College SC
- PiF: Blue Collar Shaving Mystery Box
- Thayer's Peach Witch Hazel!!
- Aftershave for a scent-sensitive lady?
- Summertime is coming
- When to apply Osage Rub?
- Are there any decent cologne-based aftershaves?
- Feather "Kanwa" Herbal Aftershave
- Three Crowns?
- clubman without seal
- Florida Water
- OS Tankard Decanter....
- thayer's
- Odd Old Spice Bottle
- Osage Rub
- Sage aftershave
- How to do an after shave/splash/ from my favorite Edt?
- Splash
- EJ Aftershave Balm Vs Merkur Slant
- Help! Which one? Never used an Aftersave
- Was I Chosen?
- Stetson Cooling Moisture AS
- Skin moisturizer as aftershave
- Sun's effect on AS?
- If you had to choose one
- Joined the Club, man.
- Alcolado Glacial
- Acca Kappa 1869 Aftershave Gel - any reviews ?
- TOBS Aftershave Question
- My wife says I smell like a ...
- Speick aftershave lotion - what is going on?
- Searching for (need recommendations)
- Special Delivery form Sweden - Aqua Vera
- Has anyone tried Deja Vu aftershave balm?
- Anybody use Clubman as a cologne instead of aftershave
- transferring aftershave to old glass bottle
- Looking for a spring/ summer scent
- Aftershave before or after styptic?
- Proraso Pre and Post Shave Cream
- Question for those who use a splash
- Best overall AS product?
- Longest lasting bay rum?
- Has anyone used Castle Forbes Aftershave Balm?
- I really am an Aqua Velva man
- Provence Sante cap
- No more Bigelow Bay Rum..... now what?
- Healing Aftershaves?
- Nivea Cool Kick
- ASB that is very 'soothing'
- T-zone vs splashes vs balms
- Travel Size AS Balms
- I thought making fun of the Veg was a joke!
- For the love of....... (4711)
- Ogallala Bay Rum
- Finally picked up some Pinaud Bay Rum
- 411 Ice ?
- The hole is too big
- SCS bay rum, Masters bay rum, and Ogallala
- Featured Aftershave - Ogallala Bay Rum
- Trumper's Skinfood
- Pinaud Naturelle Sec
- I beat the snipers on a Clubman bottle.
- Bury me not, on the lone prairie
- RazoRock Natural Handmade Aftershave Wax
- Disaster - smashed my AS Lotion bottle ...
- Can't believe no one else beat me to this
- Alum Block problem-need hel
- Help Enable My New ASAD
- Similar to Cade splash?
- Musgo Real AS
- anti-gas aftershave?
- Pinaud Clubman/ Old Spice/ Aqua Velva Musk?
- Finally found an AS to alternate with Clubman!
- Need UPC Code on Pinaud Special Reserve
- Coachman/Lustray
- Best of Fresh, Light & Clean Family of AS
- Splash & Cream/Balm
- Aloe product for razor burn
- Old Spice Pure Sport
- Helan Vetiver and Rum AS Balm
- A/S Proliferation ... how to explain to SWMBO
- Has Aqua Velva changed?
- It smells beautiful Papa!
- Master aftershaves
- Most expensive aftershave
- Proraso pre/post what am I doing wrong
- Alcohol.
- Scored Two Great Avon A/S Splashes-Pics Later
- Aftershaves and ingrown hairs
- Caesars Man AS
- another bay rum ?
- Martin De Candre Oil of Copra Camomile and lemon
- 1,000th post aftershave PIF: A sampling of my den.
- Witch Hazel is the Bomb!
- Aftershave Must Haves
- Vito's lavanda
- An aftershave with staying power?
- Lucky Tiger A/S?
- Arko Aftershaves and Aftershave CREAMS
- My vintage Aqua Velva
- Where to buy La Toja splash?
- Any scents like this?
- Caldey Island Aftershaves ...
- Crystal Deodorants as Alum...?
- My Homemade Bay Rum AS
- Superior 70...cat saver extraordinaire
- Essential Oils for Home Made blends?
- Vintage Pinaud
- Tried Alt Innsbruck for the first time today....
- Tried Superior 70 today.
- Adding Lavender Essential Oil to Witch Hazel
- Sometimes I wonder why I even try.
- Vitos Classica
- Witch Hazel
- Plain aftershave (witch hazel)?
- Witch hazel at a great price
- SCS Bay Rum with A Twist Aftershave Milk
- Avon Tai Winds = Clubman clone
- Clubman Bay Rum not actually an aftershave?
- Alt Innsbruck price increase!
- Great New Bay Rum
- I look like christmas
- question for marco #2
- Scentless AS balm/cream
- Adding menthol to favorite aftershaves
- Floid Blue & Sandolor Discontinued :(
- Avon Bay Rum - what "modern" BR smells like it?
- Osage Rub or Booster Polar Ice
- Mennen Afta - Pre-Shave
- Witch Hazel in Montreal
- The Floid Blue Scare of 2011
- Spanish Floïd with a new label?
- Pinaud Clubman ASB
- Thayers witch hazel vs witch hazel hydrolate
- Which Post-Shave Cream?
- Vitos Aftershave?
- Skin Bracer ORANGE?
- Help with next aftershave
- Second though about Superior 70
- Stephan Bay Rum - Where to find?
- Spanish Floid Suave vs. Vigoroso
- Clubman Pinaud in France
- SCS Sandalwood Aftershave Splash
- Why is Thayers AS so Expensive?
- Kanwa bottle ...?
- O Rub
- Coconut Oil
- Tried Skin Bracer for the first time today.
- Barbasol Pacific Rush < Osage Rub?
- Opinions of Mr. Taylor Aftershave
- Discovering AS splash again!
- Aftershave questions from a newb
- Osage Rub is perfect after shaving your...
- I admit it
- floid blue espana
- Superior 70
- Top 5
- Applying Witch Hazel
- VITO'S aftershaving
- Balm Aftershave Vs Liquid?